Follow
Share

My sister and I are deeply concerned that our mom is being taken advantage of by her Catholic church. When our dad passed away 5 years ago, our mom turned to the church and we were wholly supportive. But over the last few years, she has become increasingly obsessed, her once wide circle of friends is now reduced to only church members bar 2 neighbors. All she talks about is the church, it dominates her life to the exclusion of all else. She has developed friendships with priests which we worry are inappropriate (going in vacation, spending nights at her home), taking gifts etc. To clarify, these friendships are not romantic in any away more that she sees herself as a mother figure. She is talking about dissolving the family trust set up with my dad with the sole intent of benefiting his grandchildren to leave money to the priests. These are very large sums and absolutely goes against our dad's wishes and hers at the time. My sister and I don't know what to do. There is an increasing gulf between us all and we have tried to discuss it with our mom but she gets angry and shuts down the conversation. It feels like we are losing her.

Find Care & Housing
In what universe is it okay for a Catholic priest to spend the night at a female parishioners home, or go on vacations with her?????? How do you know for CERTAIN there is nothing "romantic" going on? My ex MIL was an old battle axe convinced her 30 year old broker was in love with her while he was stealing her blind! And, the Catholic priest in my diocese was having a "romantic" affair for a long time with a married parishioner and mother of my schoolmates!

There is Something Rotten in Denmark here.

Call the bishop or the archbishop and report these priests. They are not always the "holy men" they claim to be. The altar boy assaults ALONE that have been outed should be enough to convince you of that.

Also, have mother tested for cognitive issues, please.

Good luck.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

I'd call the higher ups. I'd have names and dates, if possible.

Vacations? Sleep-overs? NOT appropriate.

I would think that the diocese would be quite open to listening to you, as they're in enough trouble with inappropriate actions by priests.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to cxmoody
Report
Anxietynacy 1 hour ago
CX, that's a great idea.

On one hand I get that , this is moms business, and forget the inheritance, on the other hand , Churches can take advantage of older people.
(0)
Report
"consider if reporting the concerns to the diocese hierarchy is appropriate as priests supposedly take vows of poverty"

This was not so in NJ. Had trouble downloading the article.

"A 2014 file photo of Archbishop John J. Myers' retirement house as the Archdiocese of Newark spent more than a half million dollars for a 3,000-square-foot addition with an indoor pool, fireplaces and an elevator."

He was an Archbishop but the diocese saw it unappropriate and sold the house. So where did that Priest get his money? I would report this to the higher ups. If Mom offers gifts, they should be turned down. Staying the night is weird to me.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

If your mother has been tested and is mentally competent there is nothing that you can do. She seems to prefer her church to her family. I cannot imagine how you would be able to change that. We, as individuals, decide where to leave our money. I say this as an atheist. It seems that the church and some few within it have become, to your mother, her family. If there is no incompetence involved here then that's her choice. Your choice is only how often and how much you choose to be in her sphere; but you have no choice about where she leaves her money. And Dad is gone now, so his wishes are irrelevant.

I guess it would be best at this time that the family know it cannot expect an inheritance off mom's money.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

What you are talking about is "enmeshment" or "religious enmeshment" and as you state it's about abuse of power. If your mother is shutting down the conversation then you might want to have a blunt talk with the bishop about the behavior of the priests in question. Going on vacation with a priest is strange but having a priest stay the night at your mother's home overnight is a huge red flag. Talk to the Bishop and if that doesn't work go over their head.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Jhalldenton
Report

Going on vacation with a priest? That's a new one.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to olddude
Report

Is her intention to leave the money to the priests or to the church? There is a big difference there.

If she sets up estate documents showing the money being left to individual priest(s), I would notify the archdiocese immediately. A priest takes a vow of poverty. They have no business being the heir to a congregant's estate.

Now, if mom decides to leave the money to the church, that's a different story, and a battle you won't win if she is still with it, cognitively speaking. When dad died, mom became the beneficiary of the estate and is now entitled to do with it as she wants, regardless of your dad's wishes. It's unfortunate, but true.

If mom is planning on giving this money away while she still lives, I would tell her that it might mean a penalty if she should need long term care under Medicaid, and that you and your sister aren't going to bail her out by bringing her into your home or taking care of her in hers. If she has the cognitive ability to change her estate planning, she should have the cognitive ability to understand there might be repercussions from her decisions as well.

Sometimes, unfortunately, churches will prey on elderly people, especially those who have some financial means, to "remember" the church in their estate planning. There are actually groups of "estate planners" that will come to a church and teach the church leadership, be they clergy or laypeople, how to "talk" to people in that demographic about "estate planning". In my opinion, it's immoral, but there isn't anything illegal about it.

You might want to try a different tactic with mom. ASK her where she got the idea of leaving money to the church/priests. Talk about it in a non-judgmental way. Often, they use a mixture of playing on a congregant's guilt and pity, talking how much the church needs the money, and what good it will do. Point out that her grandchildren also need the money, and what good THEY can do with it.

It could also be that your mom feels that the church has "been there" for her, where perhaps her grandchildren have not. It's a complaint you sometimes see from the elderly, where they feel that their family is just waiting for them to die so they can get their hands on their inheritance. It's not an uncommon feeling; maybe that's where mom is with this? If so, you need to be prepared to hear that as well.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to notgoodenough
Report
JennyQ69 5 hours ago
Thank you for your very helpful reply. The priests are diocesan and can receive gifts and they have. Order priests take a vow of poverty. We have been supportive of these gifts and mom wanting to recognise the support she has received but it is esclating. We are preparing to have a sit down and openly talk through it and as you say, that means being prepared to listen.
(0)
Report
Are you certain mom isn’t beginning some dementia behaviors? Lack of reasoning skills, loss of good judgment, and obsessions can all be part of it. Perhaps it’s time for a medical evaluation, with you informing the doctor ahead of it about your concerns, but without telling mom of it. Otherwise, consider if reporting the concerns to the diocese hierarchy is appropriate as priests supposedly take vows of poverty. At the least they aren’t to take advantage of their parishioners
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

Jenny, I'm so sorry, I have seen this, no experience, on my own, but I am so sorry, I don't see that there is much you can do, unless your mom was diagnosed with dementia, and that doesn't seem the case.

I would implore mom to make sure she has enough money to take care of herself, sit down and go through everything, as for how much money she will need to go into a nicer AL, a month. All the expenses, and tell her you will not ruin your life if she gives away all of her money.

I hope others have some better suggestions for you.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Anxietynacy
Report

At This Point In time if she is in charge of the trust and has her faculties there isn't Much you can do . Perhaps you should be Happy she Has a social life and not worry about her Money .
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to KNance72
Report
JennyQ69 5 hours ago
We are very proud of our mom creating a new life for herself after the huge loss of our dad. We have encouraged her to travel, spend money on herself and enjoy the benefit of many years of hard work. Our concerns aren't about money but an abuse of power.
(1)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter