Follow
Share

My sibling has full financial control of my parents' care in AL and SIL does appointments outside as needed. Problem, she constantly complains about their depression, their cleanliness, their desire for outings, store etc. She refuses to do. We live in different states, I recently toured a facility near me to relocate them as I don’t work and did their care totally prior to my Dad's hip fx, but they talked them out of it.


I offer to try and get shut out, unless I comply and move to where they are, which I will not do, I have health issues, disabled, etc.


Every time I ask about anything it’s an act of congress.


I’ve been told by so many people to just let it go, but they’re MY PARENTS 😢

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
There's a good chance your sibling & SIL are just exaggerating your parents issues to make THEIR 'sacrifices' sound SO enormous. There's a good chance everything is perfectly fine with your folks in the ALF and there ARE no real issues to speak of, just the standard complaints of the elderly about aches & pains, the 'food sucks' in the ALF, and the rest of the usual nonsense that is NOT life threatening or overly urgent in any way. That's my call on this matter.

For your own peace of mind, take a trip down to see your folks so YOU can determine what's going on for YOURSELF. Then you can call BS on your sibling and SIL when they start in again with their exaggerated tirades. And, if there really IS an issue going on with the folks, you'll see it for yourself and be able to make an informed decision then and there.

Wishing you the best of luck seeing with your own two eyes what's REALLY going on with your folks.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
AZDaughterinLaw Jan 2023
And there is a good possibility that the resentment shown by the poster for her parent's choice to move near the brother in SIL is distorting the truth about what the SIL says or the extent of their involvement.

I do not disagree with the recommendation for the poster to visit her parents in the AL facility. I would assume she has already but if she hasn't she should. It took my equally resentful SIL for the same reason 3 years to first visit my inlaws. Granted some of that time was at the height of COVID making travel not feasible. But she did she talk to my inlaws on the phone frequently...once every three months...more if there were birthdays involved.
(0)
Report
Isthisreayreal is right. You should visit and see for yourself what your parents' situation looks like.
For all you know they could be fine and being very well cared for. It could just be a case of your SIL being a martyr who wants to complain. In her defense, it is not up to her to make sure your parents are happy, clean, and entertained. The person she should be complaining to is her husband (your brother) who controls the purse strings. He needs to take it up with the AL that gets paid to care for your parents.
Go visit though. Go and see for yourself what's going on. In a way you're lucky that you don't have POA and aren't responsible.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
AZDaughterinLaw Jan 2023
Or the poster distorting what the sister-in-law saying. If true, I agree that if the brother hasn't already that a doctor should evaluate them. My MIL was talking about death and we were somewhat concerned even though it didn't seem like she would harm herself. My husband talked to the doctor and the doctor talked to her. She is 90. He said that it is common for those her age talking about the possibility of dying sometime soon. After he asked her questions, he said she responded in a way not to be concerned.

As far as cleanliness, not sure if that is person or household cleanliness. AL's are not going to clean up everything if they are hoarders...just enough to keep their environment safe. If it is personal care, then it should be addressed if it hasn't already and the solution depends on the underlying problem. If like my MIL, she wants more outings and visits to store than feasible. We also limit it due to her vulnerability to COVID and flu. The SIL takes them to appointments. While AL can, there may be a reason for family to take them. In my MIL's case, she is profoundly hard of hearing and has memory issues so it is best for family to be present rather than have AL do it and only have the summary to look at.

I don't disagree that she should go see her mom, hang around the AL and meet other residents and staff and understand the routine. But there is nothing I see as a reason to have proposed uprooting them from the environment they chose.
(1)
Report
Have you gone to visit and see what the situation really looks like?

I would go and visit without any offer to help. Then you can see what the reality is and step in, if needed.

They could very well need a higher level of care and brother isn't seeing this because his wife has a martyr complex going on and is shielding him from what is needed, so she can sacrifice her life for them.

Obviously they don't want your help. However, you do need to put eyeballs on the situation to ensure your parents are getting the care they need. Take pictures, get parents to sign a HIPAA release for you, talk with their facility to find out what they think of how they are doing and decide what actions you need to take after your visit.

Best of luck. This is a hard situation.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

You write them the occasional nice note or give them the occasional nice phone call or text saying:

"I am so sorry to hear about all of this. I trust you to make the right decisions. Let me know if there's something I can do to help."
Then you get on with your own life.
If you are unable to do this I would see a counselor to work out what might work best for you.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
AZDaughterinLaw Jan 2023
Perfect advice! I have a SIL like the poster resentful of their parents choice where to live. Apparently, my SIL is not be able to do it because she keeps lying and distorting information and complaining. Hope the poster takes your advice.
(0)
Report
Next time SIL or sibling complain, tell them you have offered a solution but they refuse to take the offer. For personal reasons, you cannot/will not relocate.

The AL they are in should offer transportation. They should have outings where the residents are taken shopping and visit places. Call and see if they do.

How do you think you will be able to do for parents if you have health problems and a disability. And sibling holds the purse strings. Your Mom is 77 (you should take her name and birth date out of ur profile) thats not old. Her health issues will get worse as time goes on and she will need more care than an AL can give.

You made an offer, it was refused. I agree, if you can't move to where ur parents are, then ur going to need to let it go.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

If your sibling has both POA's for your parents then there really is nothing you can do, but go and visit when you can and try and be a bright spot in their lives.
You can also call them frequently to cheer them up and text them(if they know how to text.) You can also send them a "care" package of some of their favorite food items and the like. You're going to have to figure out ways from afar to bring some joy to them and be grateful that in your condition that you don't have control over them. Because as the saying goes...be careful what you wish for.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
MaryKathleen Jan 2023
"Be careful what you wish" for are true words.
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
You are expecting your parents to do something (move) that you are not willing (able?) to do yourself. Ignore the complaints and keep the ststus quo.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I'm sorry but i think your offer is ridiculous. You want your two aged probably disabled parents to get up, pack all their stuff, and move to accomodate you?because you don't feel comfortable listening to your sister's complaining and feeling guilty that you don't contribute more? WOW, wow is all i can say. You say you are disabled and can't move but number one: expect your disabled elderly parents to move? You do realize that moving is like in the top five things that are over the top stressful to people and you want to move two old people to another state? away from a town they probably are use to and know where everything is, their doctors, clinics, restraunts, parks, church? two; you are disabled.and have your own health problems?..how are you going to take care of two elderly disabled people? By visiting them in a home? A home isn't you taking care of them. It is paying someone to take care of them and believe me, what your sister is doing now for them, they wouldn't get even get close to the attention in a home. I wouldn't consider myself disabled if i could manage to take care of two elderly people even healthy ones but from the sound of it your dad has multiple hip issues and probably more to come being he is not getting any younger. Please stop. Just stop accept the guilt you are to far away to do any good or make a difference. Why not take a vacation and stay with your parents for a month or two and give your sister some assistance instead of coming up with things that just sound a bit crazy and unrealistic. You should be sending your sister any extra money you have for taking care of your parents and doing your share. Sorry i just say it how i read it.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
lealonnie1 Jan 2023
Her parents are LIVING IN ASSISTED LIVING, or a 'home' as you like to call it, already. Hello? The sibling is complaining that they're not happy which she is doing NOTHING about, and the OP would like to MOVE THEM NEARER TO HER. Yet you are treating her like she's some kind of a criminal for wanting to do so!

You owe this poster an apology, in my opinion.
(4)
Report
See 3 more replies
Well, other than moving your parents closer to you, which could hinder your sibling/SIL ability to be POA she may be more comfortable being closer and having POA, rather than not be near them to see first hand.

How, exactly, do you want to help?

You mention you are disabled? Do you have any funds to hire help for your parents? That would be a help to everyone.

If you don’t have have funds to hire help, you and your sibling/SIL need to stop this game of control. Your SIL lives closer to your parents, and has accepted the job of primary caregiver. Sure, it’s not without complaints…it’s one of the hardest jobs around.

For you parents sake, find a way to help from afar. Find a way to help your sibling/SIL care for your parents that doesn’t involve a “tug of war” between you all. Getting more help to be hands on for them would be great. Hire someone to take them out or to appts.

Your SIL may be exhausted and while you think it’s an act of congress to get info, please realize that there are not enough hours in the day for caregivers. Getting extra help hired is the best move, and if you can’t afford that, then find a way that works for both you and your sibling.

Can you visit? Can you see for yourself after a couple of days what the sitch is. Maybe you can see a more concrete way to help. I’m not sure why you want to rock the boat at this point. I’m sure you mean well, but moving your parents isn’t an answer.

Do things from afar, call them, give words of encouragement. Hire some additional help…even if you can only afford once or twice, at least it shows you understand the need for help.

Keep us posted.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This may be a blessing in disguise. You say you have health issues, so that makes caregiving harder. You say the parents are depressed and want outings. Your solution is to move them near you but the parents may still have unrealistic expectations: We want to live with you. We aren’t happy in AL. We don’t like the food. We want to go (insert location).

Maybe it’s worth a visit to understand what’s really going on before saying your sibling and SIL who are doing the work that they aren’t doing the work to your expectations. Also, if the parents are cognitively alert, they can change the POA to you - so if they aren’t willing, that speaks volumes.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter