I've mentioned this before but it came up again today and I'm wondering if there is a hard and fast rule for POAs and money.
My elderly parents have about $18K left to their names, and earn less than $1K/mo from SS. Yet today, my father spent $1,000 on a "free" book to tell him how to invest in bitcoin, promising me that the scam artist who wrote it has made millions. We were in a doctor's waiting room when he told me to watch for it, because he's having it sent to my house. I asked him what he knows about bitcoin. He said, "When they take over, money will be worthless! We'll all have chips implanted...they'll have everything and we won't have even food..." Whatever. I asked, "Do you mean aliens or the illuminati this time?" (because he's equally certain about both threats!) This time, it's for sure the illuminati. He wants to invest whatever money he has left in bitcoin...blah, blah, blah...
When the book(s) come, I'm going to send them back and demand a refund. But what I want to do it cut off their credit card (1) and turn off their internet (2) and throw their computers out the window (3). They both spend all day online, buying crap they cannot afford. In the last 10 days, he's announced he's buying a second car, a turbine (?!?!), and showed me a photo of some land he's buying in Florida for "when he retires completely". Well, ummm....he hasn't worked in 18 years, and he not only can he afford a place in FL, he can't even GET to FL without tons of help. I think they're just trying to spend money to feel free, but THEN...
My father swore that before he will let his wife move into a "nursing home", he'll shoot her dead(!) Thankfully, I convinced him to sell his guns a few months ago. But they'll BOTH be in state run nursing homes when the time comes, because they're burning through every penny as fast as they can.
I've given up on trying to persuade or be rational. May I just take away all their money? Am I allowed to do that? They signed the POA when they lived in Missouri, but now I've moved them to IL, in hopes that I could help them be a little less...wayward. No such luck!
Advice, please?
As part of setting up the Trust, we did Advanced Medical Directives, Financial and Medical POA's. I have over the course of time given up driving on my own, and I know that I am slipping in my ability to manage our financial affairs. Basically now, I just have 300.00 in one bank account each month, and I give our youngest who is in Junior High 5.00 per week allowance as long as she has kept up with her household chores. When things aren't done, I fine her if she's not doing her part to help mom. Our two oldest are over 21 and still in college, so they are doing more of the yard work, climbing ladders that kind of thing, which I know I do not have the judgement to participate in.
My hope is that family members that read this will sit down with each other and learn about what to be keeping an eye out on like finances, credit cards, ATM Cards, and if they believe their LO is financially not responsible put the brakes on. Even more importantly, at the time a diagnosis of ALZ or other Dementia ask your doctor for advice on the issues of driving, finances, where we that patient may want to be placed for Memory Care. Meet with an Eldercare Attorney, or one that specializes in Trusts and decide what fits your family best. We've engaged both the Trust Attorney, and Elderlaw Specialist work together to help make our Medical & Financial decisions are legally sound to protect the spouse that is not ill and their assets are protected. Based on what I've read these last 4 plus years, many of us wait too late and find themselves in a jam. I am happy to say we can both sleep at night, knowing we've legally set ourselves on terre firma. My DW tells me point blank when she thinks I am doing something that isn't safe, or making sense and I follow up on her suggestions because I know, she's looking out now for our best interest and we trust each other. I hope my thoughts are of some help to you.
IF YOU ARE VERY LUCKY, you have been designated as his ONLY POA, and he has no other relatives that will challenge you when you assume responsibility for him and for your mother. That will mean that when you take charge of any assets you will open a checking account with his name and yours as POA. You will have their Social Security and any other forms of income directed to that account, and you will use it solely for their expenses.
If there is another POA, or if there are relatives who will want a cut, speak to the lawyer who drafted the POA that you hold so that you are in a position to handle any financial questions/conflicts before they become problematic.
Keep up your good work. You’re definitely on the right track.
Your parents money is in danger. While it is not a huge amount, and would not go far were they to need assisted living of any kind, it is money I am certain no one wants to go into the scam sinkhole. They are more clever every day. A woman called Handel on the Law last show saying she "fell for" the "Amazon Scam" and they got into her computer, which was attached to her accounts and phone, and withdrew 2,000. She was lucky that was all that flew out the window.
The TV is internet based, but I could switch that. Hmmmm. The other big issue is that they fall for every scam call that comes in, usually giving away all their information. Last week, she called to tell me some "nice man named Clive" called and said I'd told him to call (no) and told him to tell her to give him her credit card information (which she did). The money they get still goes into the account linked to the credit card, and I can't access it thanks to Covid and B of A's ridiculous security issues. So I can't even protect them! I want to take away their phones, their internet and their one credit card! But that feels incredibly invasive for two old people who have absolutely nothing to do all day except talk on the phone and watch TV.
I don't have the education to analyze why people fall for these scams, but it's certainly not new. Decades ago when Sen. Carl Levin and Sen. John Kerry were still active Senators, I watched a hearing at which Publishers' Clearing House and others had been subpoenaed to testify. Their "testimony" was literally a dog and pony show, a more sophisticated version of carpetbaggers' approach.
Levin and Kerry lit into them, especially after a woman testified to the unbelievable amounts her mother had spent, and the bathtub full of junk which she had bought. This kind of elder scamming isn't new.
Even though there were at one time congressional actions against the scammers, I doubt there's anything like that now. So what can family do?
First, I think the big question is why do people fall for this? In our situation, I realized it was to help others, animals and people. So we went through the list of people with their hands out and selected ones that were reliable. Then I researched salaries for the execs. Anyone making over $100,000 annually was eliminated. That turned out to be the key: why would any organization have to solicit if it the funds to pay an exec big money as some of the orgs did? That eliminated a lot of companies.
Then we selected ones which were good, like Leader Dogs for the Blind, WASPS, VFW, Salvation Army. And we gave only to them. When another solicitation was received, I checked it out, and (of course) all the companies paid execs over $100K, so they were eliminated immediately.
That worked for me; if your parents are buying to HELP a company, you might try that. As to the other excuses, like bit coins and Fl (swamp)land, the only thing I can suggest is that you create financial statements for them, showing how much they have now, how long before they run out, and present them with photos of nursing homes accompanied by monthly costs.
You could also explain that running out of money would place them in the position of having to apply for Medicaid, which would even more severely limit their funding.
If TN Techie were still posting, she might able to tell you how to block the sites that advertise and solicit. I don't know how; maybe others here do. You could then tell them that the Russians hijacked the sites, or something like that, and that it takes a lot to restore them, which security experts are addressing.
With tv, can you privately eliminate the channels that has high pressure sales pitches? Maybe the cable provider can cooperate on this.
If you can, get new credit cards for you to use for them, cancel the old ones (if you have the authority to do that), but don't tell them. When charges are declined, you could tell them that they're overspent and can't buy any more, and it's again time to assess their spending.
Facing these challenges head on and frankly doesn't seem to affect the need to spend. So you may have to create work-arounds to figure out how to get them to spend healthily, only for good organizations, and perhaps even get involved in charitable activities (from home) especially as an alternative to watching tv all day long.
Are they both mobile? Can they deliver Meals on Wheels? Do any kind of charity work, especially from home? What did they do when they were young? If you can find alternatives for their all day free time, that might be a good step forward.
Don’t they have a television? They will find something else to occupy their time without a computer.
You don’t need to give them everything that they want. Children don’t need to be spoiled. Adults don’t need to be spoiled.
Today it’s a scam, tomorrow it will be identity theft.
As for spending money, set up a separate account with limited funds for them to spend. The rest is allocated for essentials or saved.
SenStruggles, are these transactions actually going through, do you know? I only ask because it's surprising that someone who's as fantastically credulous as your father appears to be can still manage the process of entering his payment and security details online. Are you sure he's not all talk?
If your POA is the durable springing type, then subject to due process (declaration of incompetence by suitably qualified person(s), that is) yes you would have the legal authority to take over your parents' financial affairs and remove their access to their money.
If not, or you can't get anyone to agree that they are now officially away with the fairies, and they really are sending a grand at a time to people who, let's face it, are not likely to be prompt with refunds... well. It won't take them to squander their remaining funds and then they'll be out of options anyway. How much trouble is it worth to you to stave off that result for a few months longer?
See All Answers