My mom lives in northern Illinois. I live in Florida and have a very happy life with my significant other of 30 years.
Mom is the primary caregiver for her husband, who has been diagnosed with dementia. She and her husband both have diabetes, and my mom’s is not well controlled.
Recently, mom fell and broke her ankle, requiring surgery. I flew in and stayed with them for a week, and my younger brother drive in from 2 hours away and stayed with them. My older brother lives 15 minutes from them, but is too busy and unwilling to check in on them.
three weeks after the surgery, mom became quite ill, but refused to call her doctor, resulting in a trip to the hospital in Thanksgiving (my older brother refused to take her and argued with her when she called him for help saying “you need to call 911. I am not taking you.”
things are complicated because mom’s husband cannot really stay home alone. He has a daughter who lives nearby and she has helped tremendously.
this has brought several issues to the surface. When I suggest caregiver support, my mom gives a resounding “no.” When I beg her to call her doctor, it’s another “no.” She feels that all support should come from us kids.
I am certain that she also feels I am her ultimate plan. She brought my grandmother to live with us, and she seems to feel I should do the same. I watched her relationship with my grandmother deteriorate, and watched every romantic relationship my mom had fall apart. She was so unhappy.
Yet I overheard her talking to a friend while I was there, and both said “you just can’t expect the same level of care from the boys.”
basically, she expects me to be her 24/7 caregiver at some point, because that is what she did, and I am the girl.
Everyone I have asked about this has said that moving her in with me is a bad idea. How do I have that conversation without hurting her? How do I convince her that I love her and I am here to help, but I do not want give up my life the way she did? Admittedly, we have grown apart in recent years, but I do love her and want to be sure she is taken care of. How do I reconcile the fact that she expects this of me automatically because I am the daughter?
I feel incredibly scared, sad and guilty about these feelings. I do not know what to do.
I raised them to be independent.
I have good kids who are there when I need them ( I am apparently starting to look fragile while caring for my husband and brother at age 76).
I cared for babies/children/young adults—— a bit different from total care of a helpless, “fussy”, perhaps huge, old person with no training.
An incontinent adult can trash a home in no time if they do not comprehend.
I have plastic over my furniture and the invalid bed. Some furniture and the carpet will have to be discarded.
Fortunately I had no really expensive furniture and I moved a lot of furniture upstairs to make room and protect some things.
I could go on. I do NOT want my children to have to live like this.
The 6 loads of wet laundry, the scrubbing, the carpet scrubbing late at night and towels thrown over to prevent a slipping that the carpet was supposed to help with..
The preparing of 6 special meals a day and late nights, the money spent because the person was not lucid to spend their own money..... NOT what I want for my kids.
People who must also work or care for growing children ....I say NO !
The second question to ask your mother is why does she feel that it is your responsibility to meet her care needs. That is a question that I can guarantee you she will stumble on because my mother certainly did. The best she could come up with is because I gave birth to you and you have to. My mother even brought up the fact that there is an old law on the books that states that the kids have to take care of their parents. She was prepared! This one question is going to open up a lot of conversations and probably a bit of yelling. Just stay calm and continue to ask your mother why she feels that it is your responsibility and duty to care for her as she gets older. Eventually she will start to understand that it is not your role and that she has to take responsibility for her own care. Now this does not mean that you would not be there to help her through the process and to help her when you are available and willing to do so. Keeping that line of communication open but defining what you are willing to do will at least let your mother know you are not abandoning her.
As for your older sibling who lives 15 minutes away, I would suggest having a conversation with that sibling and asking them what has happened that they are not willing to assist. I had the same thing in my family and it turned out that my sister was abused after the older kids had left and she just had no mental or emotional capacity to help. And to be very honest with you, I don’t blame her one bit. This may not be your siblings story but it is certainly worth asking the question so that you don’t lose that relationship. I have actually become closer to my sister than I ever have been and I’ve also learned a lot more about my own parents. Some of it was good and some it was very bad.
I hope you are able to start to resolve this issue, not necessarily for your mother but for yourself. I know how heavy this burden weighs on a person. It affects everything in your life and every moment of your life. It is a shame that some parents put that kind of burden on their children instead of working to have a loving relationship. In closing I can imagine your mother is scared of getting older but she is very lucky to have a child that is willing to assist her through that phase of life. I wish you all the luck and all the strength that you need to get through this.
Wow!!
Glad you stood strong Thomas!
Big (HUGE) difference was that I lived about 30 minutes away so I could promise to personally meet and "train" everyone who would work for her. Perhaps that is a role in which her husband's daughter and maybe even your brother can assist.
It’s 2020, and we shouldn’t even be having conversations about gender equality in this day and age!
The truth is that none of her children, male or female are obligated to care for her.
Tell her how you feel honestly and there is no need to apologize for your feelings.
Wish your mom well, offer to help her set up caregiving needs from an outside source.
She will survive and you will have your sanity and peace of mind.
Best wishes to you and your family.
"Brothers are suppose to help as well but on a different level".
I know a few men who have taken this on above their sisters. Caring is not gender specific.
nor do you have to meet your mother’s expectations. My mother admitted to me she tried to abort me when she was carrying me.
Yet I was the only one she came to for help because her son was God.
But I knew she would never be allowed to live with me. Parent’s actions have consequences too!
There was no guilt or remorse when she told me this but it sure explained a lot.
https://www.agingcare.com/questions/elderly-parents-trying-to-force-themselves-into-your-home-do-i-start-calling-senior-living-places-no-459759.htm?orderby=recent&page=2
Especially Kimber's amazing post.
The fact that you're already living so far away helps. Don't fly back up there just for a general hospitalization anymore.
Im glad to hear your mom is getting care. Thank you for the update.
You sound so much better. You are doing a great job gathering the siblings around the issues.
Here are a couple of ideas. Contact the Area Agency on Aging for your moms county to see what services are available. Here is the link for Illinois. You can ask for an in person evaluation to determine what services your mom and step dad are eligible for.
I used them in my moms very rural area to install hand rails where needed in her home and a wheelchair ramp. They did not offer Meals on Wheels in her area which would have really helped her.
My DH aunt, who lives in a different county from my mom, has had MOW three times a week. I wanted them for a wellness check. My theory is the more eyes on the situation the better.
So check out your moms county to see what is available.
https://www2.illinois.gov/aging/pages/default.aspx
Home Health Services paid for by Medicare are limited but I found them very helpful for my mom and also now for my DH aunt. You can go about starting the services a couple of ways.
1) Call her primary doctor (or endocrinologist if that’s who manages the diabetes) and ask them to order HH. If they push back, just ask for an evaluation.
2) Call a HH agency and ask them to evaluate your mom for services and they will contact the doctor with the request for the doctors order. Just have your moms doctors information to give them. Doctors phone and fax number. Some doctors are more familiar with the services than others.
The HH rep can quickly access whether Medicare will reimburse for their services.
You can find the HH Agencies on line. Your step siblings or brothers may know of someone who uses home health and has a personal reference to one.
medicare.gov has a page that will compare the ones in her zip code.
How old are your mom and step dad?
HH will do a weekly nurse visit to check on vitals. More often visits when there is an issue that needs to be followed. The diabetes being out of control might be enough to get them onboard. If help is needed for hygiene, they will send out an aide to help with baths. Occupational, physical and speech therapy can be arranged through HH. The experience I have with them has been through traditional Medicare. If a UTI is suspected, they can handle the testing. If a blood draw is needed, they can do that. I can only imagine how difficult it is for your mom to go for routine checks with needing to arrange care for her husband or take him along.
Now until December 7 is when changes can be made on insurance. You haven’t mentioned if your mom is having trouble with managing the household finances. There are usually signs if there is a problem. But it can be difficult to catch on if you aren’t in the home to see how the mail is handled or if collection calls are on the phone.
If she hasn’t already done so, putting her regular bills on auto pay is a good idea.
Your mom really has her hands full running her home, caring for her husband, managing their diets. I hope you are able to find her help and that she is receptive. It always appeared to me that even the smallest layer of help makes a difference.
Try to impress upon your Mom that the more wiling she is to utilize the help that is available, the longer she will be able to live independently.
It is a lot for you to absorb. So no doubt your mom has been struggling with it for awhile and hoping you were the answer to all her problems.
It is a bigger job than one person can handle and come out on the other side sane.
She may need a little time or even an antidepressant to absorb that while you aren’t willing to be her own personal assisted living that you also aren’t abandoning her. It actually sounds like she has a lot of help from her husbands family. Many on this site have no help from others.
It is very hard to take on the responsibility of being the sole Caregiver and moving someone into your home.
You have two choices, let her know now your feelings on the subject and what her options will be.
Or
Wait until the time comes, after her husband has to be put in a Nursing Home or has passed.
If your other two brothers aren't going to help out or visit much then you might think about finding her a Nursing Home in Florida closer to you so at least you'll be able to visit and check on her without having to fly to visit.
I guess a 3rd option would be if she has the funds is to let her pay for a Caregiver to help or if she needs constant round the clock care then she could hire a Live In and be able to stay in her own home but the cost isn't cheap but she'll be happier staying in her own home.
This is what I did for my 96 yr old dad that did not want to go to a Nursing Home.
I installed Nest Cameras in the main rooms of tge home that he goes in and hired 24 7 Care.
Of course ut's being paid by my Dad so their won't be any inheritance money but him being able to live out his life in his own home is more important.
You can check around and find individual care from $10 an hr up as ling as you don't go thru an Agency as they charge $20 and up but only give the Caregiver minimum wage.
If I were you, I would have Camera put in their homes now then you're able to tune in and see and hear what's going on 24 7 by using your cell phone or laptop computer.
a lot will depend on how she feels today, but none of us can stay with her right now, nor can we afford to pay for a caregiver out of pocket for any length of time. I have no idea how this works, but really hoping that there is a Medicare funded solution."
Here's what happened to my 92 y/o next door neighbor. She had a (partial?) hip replacement. Her 3 kids are all out of state. They had planned for her to go to rehab, but her dr. said no because of covid-19. So they had no plan. What happened? The one daughter ended up staying with Mama for a month, and now I've noticed that she's apparently taken Mama to her out of state home. Don't let this become you as the only daughter!
P.S. The woman next door lives in a large 2-story house. Her kids have tried to get her to move, but she refused. It will be interesting to see when she's brought back here to live on her own again.
a lot will depend on how she feels today, but none of us can stay with her right now, nor can we afford to pay for a caregiver out of pocket for any length of time. I have no idea how this works, but really hoping that there is a Medicare funded solution.
we are encouraging her husband’s family to get the ball rolling with some sort of care for him, even if it is in home visits. He has VA benefits, and any help for him would really help my mom since she is doing a lot of this neglect of self since she is caring for him.
greatly appreciate everyone’s advice. I really hope we can get them some help without further stress and drama. Would love to just have a day without crisis. It’s been a while since we have had a break from emergency mode.
None of you should be paying for a caregiver out of pocket for ANY time, not just for emergency or whatever. That should be paid from their income/assets, NOT anyone else in the family!
That said, sometimes there are limited funds, both income and assets. You stated he can get VA benefits - someone (could be his daughter, mom or combination of helping them get these!) should start working on that. Mom could have gotten VA aid and attendance, but long story short, the place "helping" me messed up and I gave up. Don't! He (and possibly she) can get some in-home assistance. He might qualify for VA placement.
Medicare does *sometimes* provide very limited assistance in the home and possibly a one week respite care for the primary care-giver (mom.) It does require, at a minimum, being home-bound AND accepting some personal care, such as help with bathing.
If their income and assets are limited enough, Medicaid might also provide in-home (limited) care or placement care for the husband (I don't believe you can get both VA benefits and Medicaid - go with the one the provides the most.)
You are understanding what others have gone through, which supports YOUR decision that you will not be the care-giver. We CAN support our LOs WITHOUT being the person providing the hands-on care. It is how my mother is being cared for. There is no way I could do it, my bros might as well not be part of the family (some limited help dealing with her condo and initial prep/move to MC, but basically more or less AWOL since!) I have been managing her care and finances for over 4-6 years now. One bro isn't local, done with him. The other just complained for the few things asked of him. Now that she's on hospice, I'm pretty much done with him too!
It is good to hear that both of your brothers are at the least willing to work on a plan (one that doesn't include taking care of them in home, either home!) Hopefully you can all present a united front to mom and make some progress!!!
After you have outlined what you are willing to do, you will need to have that talk with your mother. Let her know that you care about her. let her know the kinds of care you are wiling to provide. let her know the types of care that are beyond your abilities. Then, you can ask her to brainstorm with you about ways she can have the rest of her needs met.
Ask her how much she would be willing to pay someone to do each of those items. Don’t comment, just let her tell you what she expects of each item and write her answers down by each item. Tell her you will review them and get back to her.
Go away and review the list, then decide which ones you are willing to take on from a distance. Sit down with Mom again and tell her what you are willing to do and what items she will have to find someone else to do, and pay, to do.
If you don’t want to take on the role of chief caregiver to your mom NOW is the time to take a stance and say no. Even if you move her near you many of these tasks can become very time consuming.
Will her husband come too? Multiple the tasks X2 then. I was taking Mom, a fairly healthy 92 yer-old, to 2-3 medical appointments a month, each of which could consume about 3 hours for a 10 minute visit.
Please, don’t act in haste. Spend some time on this forum before you make any decisions.
We were politely direct - they did not like it. They were angry. There was yelling - attempts at guilt tripping etc. We held firm. Politely - over and over "we'll not abandon you - but you are in charge of your aging - and it is not in our home". So be ready for that.
Good luck.
Honesty is the best policy so both sides can plan properly.
It is completely unreasonable* for an adult to expect their child to put their parent’s wants and needs ahead of their own. Though some do, none the less. Resentment is almost guaranteed eventually.
This is a well meaning warning to start early. I didn’t do this enough with my own elderly mom, as she got older, and regret that a lot. You may need professional help (a counselor) with learning how to set firm and completely reasonable limits. I did. Avoid the guilt trip.
Best of luck. Please keep us up to date. You’ll find lots of support here.
Have a sit down chat with her about the in home help and seeing drs while she's at her current residence. You live too far away to give her 24/7 help and you need to know she's safe. The one sibling that is nearest her is not an option as already demonstrated. The other sibling is not that handy for emergencies. Tell her in order to stay in that house she has to agree to some help. Otherwise, she and hubby may need assisted living now to keep hubby by his daughter. If something happens to him, she could consider a move closer to you. You might throw in a comment about adult protective getting involved if others think she/hubby not able to live alone anymore.
Oh dear. I have to hope not. Because your poor mother is going to be savagely disappointed if it's so!
But don't be scared because disappointment of that sort will do her no harm, whereas you have her own example with your grandmother's care to show what will happen to your loving relationship if you try to follow in her footsteps.
Besides, it is now 2020, and you live an awful long way from your mother, and you are altogether a different sort of person.
Really you are going to have to take a leaf out of your brother's excellent book of Common Sense Told Like It Is. No, not taking you. Call 911. And meekly, like a lamb, your mother did. See the result of that? Did it mean she thinks your brother doesn't love her? No, of course not. It just meant she got treated!
And again besides, what about your stepfather? She can't suppose you're going to take him in and provide 24/7 dementia care too?
for the third time in a month we are all scrambling to get her care because she refuses to take care of herself and refuses help. Then it becomes a disaster and we are all picking up the pieces. My brothers and I all agree that this is not sustainable.
You just tell Mum that expecting you to provide care is not an option and she had better make other plans.
It does not matter what she chose to do with her own mother, you and an autonomous adult and make your own decisions.
my younger brother and I called the med facility that treated her via conf call and were directed to get her to the ER as soon as possible. She has diabetes that is barely controlled (refuses to eat healthy, etc. keeping with the theme of not taking care of herself).
older bro who previously refused to deal with her agreed to go over and facilitate getting her into an ambulance vs driving her there (I agree with this decision—she’ll likely be admitted more quickly).
younger bro is renting a car and driving to them until things get settled. I am paying for his rental since I am out of state and it’s the least I can do.
older bro is very angry at this point, but I understand his position better now.
this all has me very upset because I feel guilty for being so far away, but angry with my mom because this likely could have been avoided if she would just take responsibility for her health and accept the help that a Medicare likely would pay for.
greatly appreciate the help and support of this forum. I feel like the weak link in the chain, but trying to support my brothers as best I can from here and prepare for the difficult conversations ahead.
In some cases these changes are recognized. My eldest daughter is 58. I am 78. It would hurt me to think she would even consider giving up some of the most quality years of her life, free of job and children raised and through college, to sacrifice those years to me. We have been clear with one another that that is NOT happening. I have saved most of my life to be certain it will not. But there is a whole other group my age, who cared for their own parents, who still see that as the norm, and who expect it happen.
Sit with your Mother, tell her of your fears for her in attempting still to care for her husband in the home. Tell her that several things she has said has led you to believe that she thinks that you will be caring for her in future in your own home. That this will not be happening, but that you will never abandon her, and will attempt to help her find the best living circumstances she can for the latter years of her life.
If she asks you why give her the real answer. WHATEVER that may be. As gently as you can. For me it would be "I am so sorry, but my human limitations are many; I am not as strong or as good as others, or any way you wish to look on it; I simply am not capable of doing that kind of care. "
Don't expect her not to feel anger, grief. Don't expect yourself not to feel guilt. Are these hard facts not worth the grieving, the sadness, the pain, the confusion?
When my bro became ill, in his last tiny home, with Lewy's Dementia, age 83, there was one brief shining second after flying where he lived, when I said to myself "If you were any kind of human being you would give up your partner, your comfortable life in a place you love, and you would move here and take care of this man who was the best and most decent man you will ever know for the rest of his life". As I said. ONE MOMENT. After that, he and I were honest with one another, supported one another, did the best we could the next two years, until his death. Tears? Fears? Anxiety? Dread? Oh, my yes. Part of the price of love and our own human limitations. Be honest. Relieve yourself of this by honesty so that you don't face every single conversation with your Mom with dread.
So my suggestion for you is stay in Fla and she stay in Illinois. Research resources in her area. One of your brothers should be her POA. Not you, you r too far away. I may ask the older brother why he is so adamant about not helping your parents at all. Is it a boundary thing? He doesn't know how to set them so better to just say no? He doesn't get along with Mom or Dad? Or he is just a selfish person?
There are those on site that don't agree but you don't have to physically take care of your parents. Two women cannot live together. With you, its been 30 yrs since you have been near Mom other than a visit. IMO, living together would not work. And I hate the word "owe". Our parents chose to have kids, they chose to sacrifice for them. But as children we do need to make sure they are safe, fed and cared for but we don't need to be the ones to do it. Your brothers need to be made to realize that you are not going to be moving back to IL and you will not be moving Mom to Fla at this point in her life. So, Mom has to plan now what is she going to do when Dad gets worse or passes. You all can be supportive but SHE needs to plan her future. That she can't expect her children to be there for her 24/7. You all have your own lives and responsibilities.
You need to nip her expectations of you in the bud, meaning now. Don't wait till something happens. When you heard that conversation, that was a good time for you to sit her down and look her in the eye and say "Mom, please do not expect me to be your Caregiver because I am the girl. That has nothing to do with being qualified to care for you. You have two sons that live nearby. You need to rely on them more or find resources. I cannot be relied on living _____ miles away. And sorry, me moving back or you moving to Fla is not an option. I really don't think that will work for either of us. There are resources available you need to take Advantage of. If you need help in accessing them, I can do that"
I never had this conversation with my Mom. She was still independent till her mid 80s. Nephew lived with her and was a big help. I took her in when her care became too much for my disabled nephew. But we never had the conversation that she expected me to care for her or Dad. I really don't think she felt she would live till 89 and have Dementia. My MIL was independent till she was 91. TG she stayed in FL after FIL died. She would have relied more on my DH if she moved back.
Soooo, have that chat with Mom.
Guess what, you are ahead of the game, because you found this forum BEFORE you made the horrible mistake of taking on being your mother's caregiver out of FOG (fear obligation guilt).
Read for awhile, you will see MANY, many stories from people like me who found this forum way too late, in my case I had already made decisions about caring for my mom that I regret 100%. I moved her next to me when she decided it was time to get rolling with her elder care plan, which was me.
What I should have done when she started in with the manipulation was to stand firm and clearly tell her that I was willing to help her find senior housing, close to me, on her dime. And that's it.
Now she is right next to me, and everything is falling on me.
Do NOT be me.
Your mom is caring for a person with dementia. She FULL WELL knows the toll of this, and when you have the talk with her, mention senior living with a continuum of care "in case" she ever needs dementia care. If she gets angry, push back and say -- "Why would you want that for me?? I want to be your visiting daughter who watches out for you while you get quality professional care".
The sooner you make things clear to her the better.
One more thing- that local brother who seems to irritate you with his seeming indifference, is possibly the one you should talk to, because he seems to have successfully established some boundaries for himself. Being local he probably has seen more than you know and has wisely distanced himself from the BS.
Good luck, and remember you are ahead of the game! Need some incentive? Check out this recent thread (and there are many, many more just like it)
https://www.agingcare.com/discussions/this-is-getting-hard-463168.htm?orderby=oldest