Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

98 Answers

Most
Helpful Newest
First Oldest
First
1 2 3 4
I hope I don't get any flake for this answer. The reason is in my humble opinion, is because of the 10 commandments. Honor your father and mother. The older generation was raised on this. I am not sure I am there anymore. Likewise a lot of things in the Bible. A lot of people were raised like this and so now they think they are entitled.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
I have questions with the "honor thy father and mother" commandment. The word honor to me means to respect and make them proud. If we live a good life, that honors them greatly. This verse also assumes that a child will be raised by wise and good parents. Suppose our father was Jesse James and he wanted us to go shoot lawmen and rob banks. I wouldn't want to obey that request.

In Biblical times the Jewish tradition was for the eldest son to care for the mother if she is widowed. The eldest son also received the birthright. We see the eldest son taking care of his mother when Jesus -- Mary's eldest son -- told John that Mary was now his mother. John would take care of her.

So if anyone wants to use Biblical reference, I guess we can say that Big Brother will have to step up. Of course, he will also get the birthright -- something that might make other potential heirs a little miffed.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
There are lots of things in the Bible, but that does not mean that any possible interpretation of those things if necessarily correct. Nor does it mean cherry picking phrases to support one's ideas. Another thing to keep in mind is that the Bible was not written in modern English, so the issue of older social forms and cultural traditions has to be taken into account. But for sure, honoring one's parents is not the same as slavish obedience, self -destruction nor enabling abuse. Don't be afraid to ask questions of people whose judgment you trust as to how they interpret these things. When abuse is occurring, then you are looking at a false interpretation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
TWOCENTS - you should answer those people back with "why do you assume your children WILL take care of you? They may have their own problems!"

:-D
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
I can't begin to contribute to any biblical or other religious references! The idea of my older brother taking responsibility though...well, that ain't gonna happen.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I grew up Baptist with a literal interpretation of the King James Bible. Honor your father and mother is a commandment like Don't Steal, Don't Lie, etc.

It doesn't say that having personal boundaries and ensuring your own health and wellbeing is dishonoroable to your parents. It doesn't say to stick around and put up with abuse because of a blood relationhip. It doesn't say that you have to sacrifice your own life and livlihood to make up for what your parents failed to plan for.

Honor doesn't mean blind obedience to a person who has lost their mind. It means that I respect my parents, but as an adult myself, I get to use good sense and do what keeps them safe, clean, healthy, and in as good a shape as possible.

For those of us who came from an abusive home situation, honoring that abuser takes on a whole different meaning. I don't have to put myself in a position to be abused or experience old traumas.

I honor my abusive mother by not telling her off, not calling her the names she has rightfully earned, and not giving her the chance to behave so badly toward me. I honor her by placing her in a facility that can meet all her needs.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
I just thought of a reason such verses don't seem to fit at times. The words are intended to fall on the ears of Godly people, who would raise their children with wisdom and love. Paul said in a couple of places that parents should not provoke their children to anger. In dysfunctional families, children are often provoked beyond a point that is tolerable, with them either becoming broken-spirited or totally rebellious.

Listen to me, sounding like a Biblical scholar. Really I have problems with the Bible. I find God when I go outside and look at the stars or watch the animals. Now, if a snake walks up to me on four legs and starts talking, I might have second thoughts.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
sandwich, that is a good answer so I will try and keep it in mind. Sadly I don't have much mind left I suspect.
For whatever reason, people leave me alone on the subject of kids.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Years ago, this WWII/Korean War Gen had family close by. Many families were large. It was a given that someone in the family either lived upstairs/downstairs/next door and when they (parents) got old, they would be cared for.

I would imagine religion played a large role, i.e., honor thy mother and they father. It was just a given you'd take care of your parents as at the time they were young/middle aged adults, there was basically no place to put them.

Excellent history of hospitals after WWII and how in time they became nursing homes, then came the actual nursing home, which led to assisted living in a book, Being Mortal, Atul Gawande.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Jessebelle....very good response. We indeed honor our parents by the life we live. Not by being their doormat.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
I grew up in upstate New York and the city I lived in had street after street of 2 family homes, meaning two separate individual living spaces each with their own front and back door, 2 or 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, kitchen, large dining room, large living room, front stairwell for the upstairs unit, plus both units opened to a back stairwell, and detached 2 car garage out back.... back in the 1950's, 60's and 70's these homes were very popular.

Thus the parents would live on the main level, and a grown child along with spouse and any kids would live upstairs in their unit. It was a great idea. Of course now a days, people are scattered all over the U.S. because of employment. And getting people to move back into the inner cities, into homes with only one full bath isn't easy. These homes are now white elephants :(
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I had another thought about this after talking to one of my sisters, who reminded me that our mother displays a much greater sense of entitlement around me than around her or our other siblings. So what did I do differently from them? I moved to live near Mom in Florida at a time when all other siblings were at least 2 hours away. I think that put the idea in my mother's mind that she is still (or again) the center of my universe, like she was when I was little. I think she truly believes that I have placed myself totally at her service and that there's nothing I wouldn't do to make her happy. I've tried again and again to set boundaries with her, but it rolls off her like water from a duck. She chooses to believe I adore her and would do anything for her, and she's sticking with that story despite the evidence. And, she feels free to treat me like a child, and like a servant. I think my siblings asserted their adult independence by not changing their lives in any material way to help her, and she respects that. She does not respect me, the one who stepped up and took the responsibility because nobody else was willing to do it. Go figure!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
Another thought on "honor thy father & mother" thing.... I choose to take its meaning as telling the young to respect the wisdom of the older people who have lived through more than you have. In Bronze-Age times (when the original scrolls were written that ended up in the modern Bible), The old people were 35 or 40 years old. People just didn't live nearly as long as we do now.

But the older folks knew how to farm in bad weather, feed a sick baby, keep the roof from leaking, make the goats keep giving milk, deal with a toothache, know when it's time to migrate and in which direction, where the good fresh water springs were located, etc. Things you needed to know to stay alive. If the young will have the respect to listen and make note, they might learn something and stay alive to see 40 themselves.

CARLACB - I spent 40-something years figuring out that just because my mom treats me like a field hand doesn't mean I have to respond like a field hand. I started saying things like "that's not going to happen, you'll have to figure out something else", I stopped answering the phone if I was busy or didn't feel like talking, and I stopped jumping when she yelled.

Pulling back is a process that takes time. Find one thing you want to stop doing or let go of and just work on that. One thing at a time, one baby step at a time. Mom may never be "retrained", but you can put boundaries in place and get YOURSELF comfortable with having them. You can get the people around you trained that this boundary now exists and begin reclaiming your adult status! You can do it!!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
I think they feel "entitled" because they truly see themselves as the "Greatest Generation" -- unique, special, and deserving.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
I think they feel "entitled" because they truly see themselves as the "Greatest Generation" -- unique, special, and deserving for their perceived sacrifices.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
The commandment to honor thy father and thy mother - I know it's impolitic to say, but I think it's a crock. My parents are two of the least honorable people I've known, and they aren't the only parents in that category by any means. Words in the Bible holds no more weight for me than the words in the Koran, or the writings of Confucius.

Sandwich42, I didn't mean to imply that I haven't succeeded in establishing boundaries, only that my mother still acts completely oblivious to them. I moved 90 miles away and now see her only a day or two a week. I do much more for her than any of my siblings when I'm there, but I do tell her when I don't want to do something she asks. She doesn't like it - she becomes pushy, then whiney, then nasty. And gratitude? Forget it. When her drudge is in the house, she takes full advantage of the fact. That's why I try to never stay there very long.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Here's something interesting I learned yesterday, after going through some of my parents' files. They kept records of THEIR parents' final arrangements and expenses. I have solid evidence, in my hand, that shows that my parents were responsible in the sense that they provided oversight and managed their parents affairs when they were no longer able to. They did NOT drop their own lives (they both worked full time, and my brother and I were infants up to our teens by the time my maternal grandmother died), they did NOT impoverish themselves or sacrifice their own financial planning. I'm sure it was plenty of stress and sacrifice as it was, just making sure that their parents had the professional care they needed. None of my grandparents had assets, so their care was all Medicaid. Seeing all of this spelled out for me in black and white was reassuring. I realized how entitled my mother feels by comparison.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
With my mother, whatever I do, it's wrong. If I moved in with her, as she wants, she'd think I was "weak". She already calls me "weak" to my face, maybe because she thinks I'm a replica of my father and she thought he was weak. I feel like she's never met me - after nearly 50 years of living in three large cities, at home and abroad, and speaking three languages, I really don't identify with being weak. Anyway if I moved in with her, I'd be "weak" and she feels entitled to treat "weak" people like crap. I don't normally have anything to do with people who describe other people as "weak"; I don't think of other people like that.

Of course, if I don't move in with her and get treated like crap, I'm self-centered and selfish. So whatever I do, it's wrong. Talk about echoes of my childhood, something I don't need or deserve.

By the way, she can't figure out a bus schedule, let alone how to live in a major world city. Maybe it's projection, this "weak" stuff.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
All of this really hits home with me too.

My grandmother was Polish and the expectation in that day was that your kids would take care of you; that was their duty. She had one son, my father, who couldn't stand her. He was quite mean to her at times, I remember as a kid.

Fast forward and then he wanted and needed the help. He ran my poor sister's life. And they don't realize how much things cost, and so on. He told me he found this woman he used to work with who was now retired and was thinking of asking her to move in with him to help him. I said, 'how much would you pay her?'. He said, "whadya mean? She's getting room and board!". I said that people like that usually expect a real paycheck too. LOL, she cut him off fast!

He finally went to AL. There he drove the staff wild by hitting the call button repeately. And then he became that person who cries, Help me, help me endlessly. Finally one staff member said, Why don't you just shut up...and he did!

I have long term insurance...Hope I can continue to afford it...
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Tom Brokow got it wrong. Not the "Greatest Generation" but possibly "The Greatest Generation of Vipers". Sad when a newscaster sets us all up for heartache.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
While I don't agree with they are the Greatest Generation of Vipers (Tom Brok was talking about the WWII Generation, a generation who never had what we had as their children, i.e., the Baby Boomer Generation those born between 1945 (I believe) and 1964.

The men fought in WWII and they didn't think twice about it. They never spoke of their horrendous experiences, never complained about the PTSD they had to have experienced. When they came home, they got on with their lives. Some went on to college while many went on to factory work.

I'm sorry, but I just don't agree with your labelling them vipers. I'm upset with my mom, too, but she certainly isn't a viper.

My mother had a hard life. She shared a bedroom with at least four sisters all of whom had to share the same bed. Her dad was a carpenter from Canada (btw, the Canadians weren't exactly welcome where she settled). She had twelve brothers and sisters. They lived through the depression years. In those years, children quit school in order to work. Many gave their parents the money to help out just to buy food.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
@frequent - Me, too! Two family houses. I grew up in Massachusetts. There were also what we called 'three deckers', i.e., and if you lived on the top floor of that, you were poorer than those who lived on the first.

And this is funny, but today, the apartments are being turned into condos with each floor going for at least, at least, $350,000 to upwards of millions, depending on location.

And this is the funniest. The top floors are now often called the PENTHOUSES! and are often the most expensive.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
OMG, I left off his name...it's not Tom Brok! I was looking up how to spell it because it didn't seem right. It's Tom Brokaw. Stupid me :)
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Oh, and one more thing about the Greatest Generation. They had to watch as their world collapsed into what they believed was chaos with the rioting, their sons turning into long haired hippies, and the list goes on.

Today, we, in turn, are watching as our world turns to terror. Given the news these past few days (actually, months) this doesn't sound good.

So, while I am upset my mom is getting older and no longer has the capacity to care for herself, and while I am upset that she says stupid things, does stupid things, and the list goes on, I would never have called her a viper.

We never know how we will be when we get to be 91. My mother's landlord who is 91 also tells me "The 'golden years' aren't so golden". And I remember years ago, Art Linkletter, wrote a book entitled, "Getting old isn't for sissies'.

When I was studying Grief and Bereavement back in the good old days of the year 2000, it struck me just how much our elders lose when they get old. I'd never thought of their losing the ability to read (i.e., loosing their sight) or the ability to drive (i.e., losing their independence); or the ability to even wipe themselves. I mean, gees, coming to you in the next twenty to thirty years.

Right now I'm gathering forms to submit to Medicaid (another horror!) and I'm feeling like I'm going to send my mother to a prison she may never leave. It's not easy and it's certainly not something I wish on my children. But we have the foresight many of them didn't have or didn't even talk about. WWII generation never spoke of death. It was just a taboo subject. And to pre plan their funerals was certainly out of the question, at least the people I knew.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Litldogtoo: It was Our Lord and Savior that termed the "generation of vipers". There are vipers in every generation. The fact that one was called the greatest by a newsman doesn't make it so.
The fact that all these medical advancements occurred for the most part by this generation to keep us around well after the quality of our lives has past I do NOT believe is a commendable thing. I believe it is purely a money making venture and as any such venture we all suffer for it.
I have no intention of filling the pockets of the wicked so I may stick around past my time. I am not that selfish.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
So sorry, Learning Curve - please don't tell me what it says in the Bible....because from the Bible, I take it as holding a negative connotation, i.e., Jesus doesn't use it as something good. In fact, he condemns them to hell. Not exactly what I would call the WWII Generation.

I would suggest you actually read what I wrote and not just take a few words of mine out of context. You likened the WWII generation as a Generation of Vipers. That's a serious accusation.

I'm not going to answer you again as I feel this has no place on this board, but the original question was why do 'some' parents have a sense of entitlement" ...

At times I feel I should even participate in subjects like this because there is just no winning against people who feel as you do. Kind of like participating in the conversation with the woman who is 'scared', i.e., she's angry at everyone.

So sorry if I insulted your intelligence and understanding of the Bible, but you have to remember that many of us don't consider our parents as a generation of vipers. Jesus meant it as being derogatory. While I don't like having to care for my mother in this case, I'm certainly not going to allow someone to lump her into a phrase as being a viper.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
When my mom felt she was a burden i would always say to her, you were there for me all the times I needed help. I had twins who were 3 month premature and my parents were with me every step of the way! I could not have done it without their help. However, once a person becomes defendant on another i think they have expectation that they want met. Some of which are doable and some of which are unrealistic, especially when there are spouses and children that are also in the picture .
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Many people have responded that they are caring for parents who did not care for nor show their love and support for their children. I am sitting here thinking that hopefully this type parenting will not be continued in future generations of your family. Some of the posts I am reading are so sad! My heart goes out to many of you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
littledogtoo, the things you wrote got me to thinking about how things are for people that are 55-70 now. They had their own children that they cared for, then fledged them. The last one might have left the nest when the parent was 50. Then Dad gets sick, then Mom gets sick. We care for one, then we care for another, going through the trauma with each parent. And then -- goodness! -- we're old ourselves. Maybe we care for our spouse as our own health declines. Often it is only one person in a family that does the caregiving so that other people can live their lives without all the extra weight. Then the caregivers realize they never got to go on that trip to Hawaii or that cruise to Alaska, and their golden years are fading fast.

It would be enough to make me sorry for myself, but then I remember that I don't like long plane flights and Alaska sounds mighty cold right now. So maybe it is okay that I'm here with a woman who isn't very pleasant who tells me many times how she enjoyed her trips when she was younger. Grrrr! Sometimes she says things like "When I was your age, we used to go hiking in the mountains." I remind her that at my age she wasn't taking care of her parents.

Someone has to do it. I guess we're a group of the annointed few. Sometimes people tell me that my reward will be great in heaven. I don't know about that -- I can think some really sinful thoughts with the things that go on every day. I think I would have a better chance of going to heaven if I weren't a caregiver!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Jessebelle you had me smiling. You hit the nail on the head! Hubby and I (he is 70 and I am 66) talk about vacations but as long as I am the only sibling looking after dad's care and financial responsibilities it will not happen. Dad is 91 and though he is in hospice care he is doing much better than I thought he would. He expects a lot from me and doesn't consider our age and health. He thinks I can drop everything and travel the hour and a half to take him a dozen McDonald's chocolate chip cookies. Then an hour and a half back home! I do not want to do this to my children.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
1 2 3 4
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

Recent Questions


Popular Questions


Related Questions

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter