I am one of 5 siblings. We live 1 1/2 hours to 8 hours away from parents except for youngest 53 yr. old sis who is unemployed and lives with parents. Dad diagnosed with Dementia 3years ago and is mid-stage while Mom, 85, we strongly suspect has had mini stroke. Struggles to put sentences together, forgetful and easily confused. Sister is dual diagnosed bipolar alcoholic who denies this and is untreated. My other siblings and I feel Sis is doing the minimum she can. We want her to take a stronger stand and get on a schedule where they take their meds daily, shower a couple of times a week, get medical care even when they refuse (Sis gives up and Mom just had bronchitis and pneumonia because she would not go. Another sib went to visit and MADE her go see doc) fix at least one decent meal a day, clean a bit. I live 8 hours away and drove to see them last week but only gave them 1 hour notice to see what conditions were like. Had to scrub potty before I would use it, etcetera. Sharing our concerns with Sis is met with defense and pronounced paranoia. She lies and has tried to start trouble between each of us to deflect her problems. Parents did not plan at all for retirement and very little money. The sibs can do a little but not much. We are checking into caregivers but money is an issue for us. We are also concerned about Sis when parents are gone as none of us will take her in. She has 3 degrees but cannot hold down a job. How can we get help for parents and make, force or require Sis to get treatment? Our pleading does no good and Mom backs Sis and thinks she does a great job. Refuses to see lack of care and finds excuses for everything. Dad's dementia diagnosed 3 years ago and neither have read anything on disease, joined support groups or sought help from social agencies despite our giving them many resources.
I would suggest you gather as much information as you can about which assistive living facility you would choose for your parents and how they can afford it. Look into subsidized housing options for your sister. Have a plan in place for when it all hits the fan and then stand back and wait. You can't force any of them to change or see reason.
Oh, I do hope someone responsible has poa and not sis, because then you will be powerless when the time comes.
sorry but ive been in the carer situation with jealous sibs negging from a distance .
helping your sister and the parents out in a real way would be a lot more constructive .
mom is 3 yrs gone . im still a maniacal boozer -- my two sisters are still intellectually disadvantaged , or whatever the current term for half witted is ..
Find a way to help on a regular basis. How about one weekend a month? Take a walk in your sister's shoes.
It is very sad but family dysfunction that has long been gone once children marry and have their own families, sure rears its ugly head as parents age and need their children to get along and cooperate with one another.
How do you know sis's ailments? Did you talk with her doctor? One of my twisteds is a therapist and has diagnosed many family members including me. Not at all appropriate since she uses this information and diagnose while pitting family members against each other.
There really is plenty that you could do to help. I think there are suggestions even in the 36 Hour Day. Once folks see you and your siblings working together, things will be easier for them and everybody. It is easy to watch from a distance and be critical, it is harder to watch from a distance and be supportive. There must be something your sister is doing right.
I had these discussions with the twisteds numerous times, they still would not get it or understand. They thought the care was easy and they would be ok by themselves. At least until the move, just about a year ago. My mom with late middle stage Alzheimer's went off the deep end. Kicking and hitting other residents, screaming, trying to climb eight foot security fences to get out. You name it mom did it. Yes, with mom at home it was relatively easy care, only because she had somebody familiar caring for her.
Just find a way to be supportive of your sister. You may be surprised what just a bit of kindness and appreciation will do.
Are they safe?
Are they comfortable?
Are they content?
you are doing a good job as a caregiver. My three other siblings and I do not feel they are. I am not alone. The social worker I spoke with here said last week I have described elder abuse through neglect. My grandmother had Alzheimer's and I know how it is there now is a cakewalk compared to what is going to be. I have an appointment with a geriatric case manager this week. Perhaps I should just leave it to the pros. Thank you for taking the time to post your thoughts.
I'm not sure what kind of advice you are hoping for, it seems you won't consider AL for your parents, they can't afford paid help and in my opinion it is unrealistic to expect your sister to do more than she is willing or able to do. As I said before, you can't legally force any of them to change things if they are not willing.
I hope the GCM is able to offer your parents assistance, Kathy.
You have a sister that you KNOW is bipolar and an alcoholic AND doesn't take her meds, and has no income and is totally reliant on parents for anything and you wonder what is so wrong that she can't do the bear minimum in terms of care? Its not by accident that bipolarity used to be called manic depression. The mood swings in a relatively 'normal' situation can be bad enough to cause some BP sufferers to commit suicide and your sister is by no means living in a normal situation. In fact she needs to be cared for too which I know is not something you want to hear but it is fact.
You write We have to focus on Sis as she is their full time caregiver. She stays in her bedroom 80% of the time watching TV or sleeping. She does not get "paid" but she has free room and board, use of their car anytime she wants and does not contribute for gas or insurance. Respite care? I cannot go stay for two weeks with them and where would Sis go anyway? She has no income and no friends whatsoever. .......Just untreated mental illness and no discipline results in an unstable environment for the entire household.
It actually isn't a wonder that your sister's bipolarity is deteriorating. She isn't LIVING at all she is existing, she will know she is dependant on them and that wont improve the situation and she wont be able to see any light at the end of the tunnel.
In my truly honest opinion you need a family meeting. You need to all be there and all be as honest and as open as you can about the needs of each of you and of your sister and of your parents. An absolutely open discussion about who can do what and when and how and how much you are each prepared to take on. AT NO POINT should your sister feel positioned somewhere with an insistence that she take on the role of caregiver - she really isn't capable of so doing. Caregivers have to be 100% reliable - hell I have written books on dementia and I wasn't remotely prepared for the road ahead of me and I bloody hate it. Would I tolerate criticism in any form - however mild? not if you want to keep your head !! If anything your sister is really being badly abused (not deliberately but situationally) and it is SHE who needs to be in a secure environment...then worry about Mum and Dad.
If she is going to do the caring and the level of that will need to be reviewed then she has a RIGHT to be paid for that. Would you take on a role that has the potential to become 24/7 for just room and board? Even if her role only takes up 20% of her life that is still over 30 hours a week and she should be paid for goodness sake.
However if she is going to care then she needs guidelines some of which MUST include regular treatment and adherence to medical regiment that the doctors prescribe.
Meanwhile APS MUST be able to address you concerns and could possibly offer guidance and help and if not does your social services not offer something along those lines? What would be really helpful would be for a member of the social services team to be there for the meeting to sleep you all on the straight and narrow.
If your Dad was a Vet could he not access VA benefit?
Your words: "I do not think it it unrealistic to expect my sister, who has lived with them for 10 years and has never held down a job for longer than 3 months (and nothing at all the last 7 years) to cook one meal a day, make sure they take their meds, " etc.
It is not unreasonable to expect that an average or below average person could do that. It is UNrealistic to expect that your sister will be able to do this. Why? Because she never ever has, and probably won't start now.
I think you are trying very hard to be a good daughter and sister. Your family is in a terrible situation, and you are trying to make things work out. You need a lot of help. and I hope you can find it.
My bipolar formerly alcoholic brother is being treated, and that helps a lot. Still, he is subject to outbursts and inappropriate behavior where our mother (whom he adores) is concerned. For example, when Mom fell in the nursing home he went off on a tirade against the staff, blaming them, talking about suing, etc. Us sisters went to the staff involved and to their bosses and explained Bro's mental illness and assured them that he didn't speak for the rest of the family and that he was very good with Mother. We did not want him banned from the NH! We also talked to him when he was calmer. He now visits on Sundays and plays cards with Ma. She loves his visits. He would not be the right person to be in charge of decisions for her, but he is a loving son and we try to support him in that role.
If Bipolar Sis can't be relied on to provide meals regularly, how about something like Meals on Wheels for all three of them?
If she is not a dependable homemaker, why not bring in a cleaner once a week or twice a month, as needed?
It seems to me like these three people have made their bed and are lying in it more or less comfortably. Captain's tone is a little harsh, but I tend to agree with his observation.
Help make their situation better, or stay out of the picture.
Our mother has had dementia at least 5 years. Of her seven kids, I am the ONLY one who has read extensively about dementia, attended seminars, belongs to a caregiver support group, participates actively on AgingCare. (I started this when my husband was diagnosed, a few years before my mother.) Does this make me the hero and authority in my family? Ha! It makes me a bit of a suspect, if you want the truth. The fact that Mother and Sis haven't educated themselves is sad, but not at all uncommon and not grounds for assuming they are bad caregivers.
When my brother was in crisis mode and us sisters finally "got it" about his mental illness we asked him what we could do to help. He begged us to read about his disease. What an eye-opener. I wish I'd known more about bipolar disorder much earlier!
It sounds like there are three people in that household who deserve understanding. Yes, it would be nice if they all learned about each other's maladies. But the person whose education you can control is you. I hope you'll be mindful of your poor sister's handicaps, too.
Im out of here. Anyone who can't understand that bipolarity affects different people in different ways is not someone I am going to waste my breath on.