Follow
Share

My 95yo mother made a comment a couple of days ago after I asked her how she was feeling. Her answer was "Are you waiting for me to not feel good?" I was shocked to hear that because I've been the person who has helped her, taken her to numerous doctors appointments and called her daily. I've been the only person she relies on. What the heck?

"How are you feeling?"
Are you waiting for me to not feel good?

I'm not waiting for anything. (argh....)

So typical of the unappreciative Elder. You need some better opening lines:

Do you need me to do anything today?
I love that pink blouse on you!
Want me to get us donuts?
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Dawn88
Report
AlvaDeer Jun 3, 2024
Yes, I will love the donuts, thanks, Dawn. Chocolate icing, please. Lots of it.
(3)
Report
I myself, as an 81 year old woman find that question you asked, odd.

For instance, if I can, as your friend, to visit you, Julie. Say for a cup of coffee in the morning. And I looked at you and said "Julie, how are you feeling?" would you not find that an odd question? Might you kind of wonder ----"geez, am I not looking great?"

I had a surgery recently. In in the morning, out in the afternoon. All who knew me knew I was having it. Knew what I had and why I had this surgery. And for a few days after, I found it caring and normal to hear "so, how are you." But I have to tell you after a month or so, when I was clearly back to my normal life, I found it odd when someone ask this seemingly caring question "So, how ARE you". I just wanted to say "Great! And if I ever DON'T feel great, you will be the very FIRST one I tell".

I can't tell you why that question is grating to some of us? Almost "diminishing", but it IS.
So, I guess your Mom and I are sisters of other mothers.

I know you were well intentioned. Next time you go just say "Mom you look GREAT. That sweater is a great color on you", and on you go. We old gals just get too danged sensitive for our own good; what can I tell you.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
Anxietynacy Jun 3, 2024
I would think it might depend on the tone too. If it was just a brief , how ya feeling. Or a look at you sadly and say it in a like slow motion kind of way, that is kind of degrading, to the person being asked.

I have a neighbor that ask nice questions but her tone makes me think, she is hoping for a bad response, like she doesn't want a good response because inside she is hoping things are not good. Because she just doesn't want anyone to be happy.

Some people my not even know that they're tone is degrading, and not mean it that way
(1)
Report
Try switching to , “ Is there anything you need?”
You never know what may annoy a 95 year old .
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
lealonnie1 Jun 3, 2024
Nor does one know what may annoy a daughter into not doing all that she does for the 95 year old mother for a week or two.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Have to laugh here.. When I've asked "How do you feel?" or "Are you feeling OK?" it usually is because someone looks a bit.. off.

I asked my DH how he felt a while back. "Why!??" he says "Do I not look my perfectly perfect self?. Do I look BAD or something?? 😆

Umm yeah.. you look kind of shrivelled & a slighly funny colour. Like when you got Covid.

I'd just laugh that off with your Mother. My Grandmother would have stopped, stared & said Well. OLD. Tired. But still here!!!
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Beatty
Report

I think it’s a regional thing.
How are you or how are you feeling is a polite greeting in my world, so if that’s not her usual type reply, I might be annoyed as well or think she isn’t feeling well. If she does it again ask her if she meant to be rude.

My MIL used to reply,
”Don’t get old, dolly.”
She called everyone dolly. That alone made her eldest son angry.
Another would say, “fair to middling.” And I remember “with my hands.”
My DH aunt would say “If I felt any better, you and I both would be in jail.” What that meant, I have no idea.
One old guy would give a weather report. “With my arthritis I think it’s going to rain.”
If possible, just come back with something to lighten the mood and move on.
I notice my sister always says, “Good. Real good.“

I asked an old uncle one time if he had any major maladies and he answered with my all time favorite “Not likely to say”.

I just laughed but he hadn’t worn out my good will as your mom may have done at this point for you.

I hope it goes better next time.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to 97yroldmom
Report
Geaton777 Oct 24, 2024
97, I had a very elderly Italian-American relative from the Bronx who called every woman Dolly. "Hey Dolly" and with the Bronx accent. So funny to read about yours...
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
My 95 yo mother would've said, "Why, are you waiting and hoping for me to drop dead or WHAT?"

Consider yourself supremely blessed if this is the first time mother has shocked you with a semi-snotty remark! My mother thrived on them 🙄
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

It is genuinely difficult to know how to pitch “How I feel” and also “How do YOU feel”. My DH is down getting the farm and its equipment ready for sale. It’s a huge amount of work, I know quite well he is exhausted, lonely and stressed out. But it just has to be done. He doesn’t want to upset me by complaining, but I need to know how he is coping.

It’s much the same with me. My scoliosis is fairly painful most days, I am not infrequently tanked up to the eyeballs with codeine, lying on the floor on top of a hot water bottle. To make it worse, this ‘vestibular disorder’ is really off (it means that the world wobbles and I am prone to falls). I’ve just moved to a new place where I have very few friends. I need to let Tony know that it’s being quite difficult for me too, but that I am also coping. (I don't whinge like this to him, because he already knows the details).

We telephone each other twice a day, and this difficult balance is with both of us every time. We do the best we can, to be honest but not worrying. This may be a fairly extreme situation, but the elements of it are with all of us some times. If you can do better with your Mother, good luck to you! And to M! Write a book about how to do it!
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
97yroldmom Jun 3, 2024
Margaret
Thinking of you and DH. I hope the sale goes smoothly and he gets home soon.
(3)
Report
See 5 more replies
I think it falls along the lines when 90 year Olds in a senior facility feels that everyone around them is too old. Take it as a grain of sand and don't take it too personal
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MACinCT
Report
Anxietynacy Jun 3, 2024
I agree, that and also find me someone over 90 that's going to say, I feel great. Your not going to feel good at 95
(1)
Report
If that’s the worst she’s said..I’d celebrate ! Count yourself and your mother lucky and blessed
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to CaregiverL
Report

I work in a care home and one of the people I look after is 95 , in bed most of the time and I really push the boat out for her . The more I do for her , the ruder and more disrespectful she is. I shop for her and get her clothes and she is initially grateful , then she’s shouting and screaming at me. The next day , she’s crying and apologetic. And telling me she loves me really , then it all starts again . I’m not her daughter . , although she does have one , and invariably they do not get on . She feels very sorry for herself , and I think just bitter towards the world in general . Getting old is not fun , and it will often depend on their quality of life as to how the elderly behave. . I certainly wouldn’t want to swap places . I value every day in having a normal life . Even to be able to take yourself to the toilet is a blessing and a privilege. You’ve been a wonderful daughter to your Mum, and it’s hard when they appear not to appreciate you . I’m sure she loves you dearly really , but she probably no longer likes herself , and remember , they usually take out their feelings on people they love , and who love them . They’re the ones they can trust to always be there for them .
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Deedee27
Report
BurntCaregiver Oct 24, 2024
@Deedee27

You did not make the 95 year-old resident in the care home old. You're not to blame for her old age or whatever pain and health conditions she has. Never let a care client ever get so comfortable with you that they feel safe making you a target for their abuse.

I worked as a caregiver for 25 years and also did for my manipulative, abusive mother. I learned early on that you DO NOT tolerate rude and disrespectful behavior from anyone regardless of their age. Being old does not give a person a free pass to be an a$$hole to whoever they want.

Why do you think your client doesn't get on with her daughter?

If she's being rude and disrespectful to you or screaming and yelling at you, you cut her off. The way to do this is to look her plain in the face and tell her that you will not tolerate her behavior and if it continues you will be forced to talk to the administrator of the facility about her. After you have said this tell her that the crocodile tears do not stir your sympathies and that you don't want her fake apologies.

If she's truly sorry for her behavior towards you, she will stop behaving such to you. Tell her all of this.

If she continues to treat you so badly, tell your supervisor that you will not provide care or assistance to that resident.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter