I am a mother of a son and a daughter. I try my best to be a good mother and a good daughter, but very often I don't know if I have done the right thing. My pain come from my bad relation with my mother. I know I should love her but to be honest, I do not like her. I think she is mean, dishonest, partial and stubborn. She has a tongue of stagger, often hurting family members. My father got lung cancer and is in bad condition. He cannot speak, cannot eat with mouth, cannot hear anymore. Instead of understanding his agony and giving intensive care to him, she complained very often about my father' bad temper and doesn't want to do housework. My sister ( who has more time than me since her children are in universities in another city) gives most care to my father, cooking,washing, and feeding. I try my best to offer some help, but my help is limited and mostly is financial because I have two children to care, and my husband often goes out of town for business, and my workplace is very far away from the town center where my mother and I live. Last week my father sent me a text, asking me to ask leave from my work so as to help my sister and my mother with housework. To tell the truth, I was somewhat unhappy about this, because I think my sister and my mother can handle the housework, there is no need for me to ask leave from my work. So, I texted my father and told him about my difficulty. He is understanding. Anyhow, I do not want my parents and my sister think I am avoiding the responsibilities I should take. Before my father's text, I went to see them everyday after I have picked up my daughter and stayed for an hour. While I was there, I would talk to my father by writing, and gave some help. My sister would do the cooking, because most of the time she has come back from work and has begun cooking when I came there. After my father's text, I managed to go to my mother's in the afternoon earlier than before and helped to do cooking and some cleaning work. I went there at about 4:00.As soon I got there, I started to work. I cleaned the floor, and I prepared all the food for my father and cooked the meal for my mother, my sister, and her husband,who sometimes comes for dinner but not everyday. Then, I left at about 5:00 to pick up my daughter from kindergarten. While I was doing all these, my mother was sleeping. I could feel that she was pretending sleeping,because every time I got there and was unlocking the door, I could hear the sound she made when trying to go to bed quickly. She would sleep on bed and didn't get up until I left. However, I didn't say anything about this. Yesterday, I went there at about six after I have picked up my daughter.My mother has got up. My sister has not come back from work, and I started to cook as soon as I arrived. I was in a hurry because I had to go back home to cook for my son, who would be back home from school at 7:30. My mother told me not to cook too much because she was not sure whether my sister' husband would come for dinner. When I finished cooking, she came into the kitchen and said very angrily to me that I have cooked too much because my sister' husband would not come back for dinner ( while I was cooking my sister came back and told her that. I din't heard this. But I know my problem was I should have asked my sister when she came back about this but I didn't. ) I explained to her it was not too much. She wouldn't listen. She went on blaming me that I cooked too much on purpose. She said I cooked too much because I didn't want to cook for them. She said I was showing my unwillingness in this way. She said I cooked too much because I want them to eat leaf over tomorrow. She said I didn't want to cook for them because I seldom talked when I was there. She said she would not eat the meal and asked me to take the meal I have cooked home. I was very angry when I heard this and lost my control and yelled at her. I said she was doing too much to me. I said I was not as bad as she had thought. I said she has wronged me. I said I didin't talk because I didn't have time to talk. I was so angry that I shouted at her. I did all this in front of my four year old daughter, which put me into greater pain, because I have always wanted to set a good model to my daughter of being a good loving daughter. I failed again. Similar things like this happened several times.Whenever I am in such bad situation, I am on two minds, which is an indescribable torture. On one hand I am bothered by the sense of guilt. I think I should try my best to make my parents happy and take good care of them and tolerate everything. On the other hand, I do think my mother is too demanding, and too mean and unreasonable. Moreover, I am afraid my kids might think I am not a good daughter and will not respect me. Whenever I was in conflict with my mother, I need several days to recover, to forget all the painful feeling. I could not concentrate on my work, kids and husband. Please help me. Thanks.
Yes, it would have been better not to have an outburst against your mother in front of your young daughter. But in my opinion it would have been even worse to just stand there and accept your mother's irrational anger. Is that what you want your daughter to think is her role in life? Yes, it would be better if you could have stood up for yourself more politely. Guess you are not perfect, huh?
You might tell your daughter something like, "I was very angry at Grandma today. I lost my temper when I talked to her. Next time I am so angry I will try not to lose my temper. It is much better to be more polite. Sometimes people who love each other very much are angry with each other. It doesn't mean there is not love and respect between them." This is a good thing for a 4-year-old to know.
I think the advice Jeannegibbs is good. If you lost your temper and stood up for yourself that is okay. It sounds like your mother is putting you in an impossible situation. It is a good idea to set a good example for your child and the best thing you can do is be a good parent to her. I would also advise you not to say mean things about other relatives to her because THAT will upset and confuse her a lot.
As much as you can, keep her away from these adult conflicts, but do not be a doormat for your mother just because your daughter is there. Obviously you were put in a difficult situation and also your mother is having trouble taking care of your ailing father.
Do your best.
Why do you need to cook for your mother, father, sister, brother in law, your husband, yourself, your 2 kids and go to work as well?
It sounds to me like there are 5 adult people who are capable of cooking and cleaning.
Grandma, sister, brother in law, you, your husband.
It sounds to me as if you are the one with the least amount of time available to do this, as you have a job and primary care for 2 young children.
Think it through. Try to help your father and set a limit. Do not engage in arguments with your mother AT ALL. Set the limit for yourself and your children. It seems the main purpose of your visit is to assist your Dad. Just do your best. If your mother is angry, fine. Leave and let her yell at the wall. Don't argue with her and don't let her yell at you. You are going way beyond to help. She should not be yelling at you and you should not be stretching yourself so thin to help when you have other responsibilities and there are others there that are just as capable with more time. If some one has to eat leftovers or a re heated dinner that is not the end of the world. Your father has lung cancer and cannot speak. The purpose of your visit is to help him, not be a target for your mother's rage.
Don't let them take advantage of your good nature. Do your best, go home and be at peace.
Please know that you do not have to be intimidated by your mother or your father, or guilted into doing things that may not be necessary at that particular time. Talk to your sister and work out a solution that works for both of you. It also doesn't have to be equal as people are often at different points in their life and one is in a better position to help more. If you can help financially, consider sending in a cleaning service once a week or every other week or having prepared food delivered as your contribution to their care and support. Let your mother and father know that that is how you are contributing. Then visit with your children when you can have a more calm encounter.
You do not have to submit yourself to the manipulation and verbal abuse of your mother and unreasonable demands of your father. You are a good daughter because you obviously care and are trying to help. And please, stop feeling guilty or remorse, just start working on a solution. Sort out a way to help that fits for you and doesn't destroy you, your relationship with your children and others important to you.
Good luck. I hope you find some peace.
First let me say that you can never make someone else happy. Never.
Also, there seems to be a disrespect of you by your mother. She seems to not appreciate what you are willingly doing to help her. Maybe your culture dictates you be at her beck and call but I see no respect for you.
My mother died 6 months ago and even in her last two months of life chose to disrespect my efforts to cook, clean and nurture her. She chose to be like your mother and talk about me behind my back. Everything wrong with her car, home and life in general was my fault.
I would see if there is some way you could hire more help or get more people on board to give a hand in this situation. Then I would have a big wake up moment to the more than likely life long abuse you have suffered. I have been in your shoes and can tell you your mother does not think about your feelings one bit. So you start thinking about them.
I agree with someone here who said to let your young daughter witness your mother's abuse and do nothing is harmful. Your daughter will pick up clues as to how she can expect to be treated in the world. I wouldn't allow my children around an abusive grandparent.
Stop feeling as if you are to blame. Your mother's behavior is to blame. My mother's behavior was to blame. And she went to her grave being a mean, vindictive old lady. Not my choice, hers.
Good luck to you and seek some professional help. Also don't let the "but it's our culture" be your excuse. All people deserve respect.
See All Answers