Follow
Share

My brother is our father’s enduring POA, and has control of his finances, but I have father living in our home. I take care of his meals, medication, doctor appointments, showering etc 24/7.


When all this was done with our father’s lawyer, my sister didn’t bother signing her part of guardianship and still hasn’t done so. I am my father’s enduring guardian.

Find Care & Housing
The term 'Primary Caregiver' is not a legal term and it does not give a person legal authority to make decisions for another.

If you have POA (Power of Attorney) or legally-appointed conservatorship/guardianship of your father, this gives you the legal authority to have him placed in care, to administer his money and assets, and to make his medical decisions.

I was an in-home caregiver for 25 years by profession to more people than I can remember. Often times I was someone's "primary caregiver". It means nothing other than you're the one responsible to meet the needs of the person and you do all of the work, or at least the lion's share of it. You have no legal authority over the person you're taking care of.

So yes, if you do not have your father's POA or there's no conservatorship/guardianship not only can your siblings legally stop you from placing your father, your father can legally stop you too.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
sp196902 Jun 13, 2024
They can stop the OP but that doesn't mean the OP has to continue to allow the dad to live in her home or take care of him. She might have to evict him to get him out though.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
If you don’t have control of your father’s money , I don’t see how you can put him in care to begin with .

Do not sign anything as guarantor making you responsible for your father’s bills .

Tell your brother who does hold the purse strings that you can no longer care for Dad . You may have to actually leave Dad on your brother’s doorstep to get him to place Dad .
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to waytomisery
Report

It all depends on how the guardianship reads. Usually when this is done the person requesting gets full control. POAs become revolked. But I guess u can get guardianship without conservatorship?

You need to tell brother you no longer can care for Dad. His needs are too much. No one can be forced to care for someone. If he does not take over then call APS. Tell them you can no longer care for Dad and the POA refuses to use Dads money for his care.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
BurntCaregiver Jun 13, 2024
Usually guardianship come swith conservatorship if the court is appointing someone. Of course a person can consent to it and it can be done by a lawyer, but usually they don't.

Most people just do a POA with a lawyer and names one of their family members.

If there's already a POA and it's Durable and covers more than just finacial for the father, that person is legally respnsible for him.
(0)
Report
I for one am confused by your use of the terms enduring POA, guardianship and enduring guardian - a lot of people come to the forum and use the terms guardian and guardianship when that is not what they have at all, I think a visit with your lawyer is in order so you can be clear what your duties and responsibilities are.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to cwillie
Report
LaGorda58 Jun 14, 2024
Im from Australia, so these are the terms which I will use, regardless of whether you understand them or not. I don’t know how it works in USA, but I’m pretty sure I was present when my father reluctantly made my brother his ENDURING POA and my sister and me his enduring guardians. I don’t know how else to explain it to you. I feel my brother manipulated my father into choosing him for POA.
(0)
Report
I do not know what you mean about being "my fathers enduring guardian".
If you are talking about LEGAL Guardianship/conservatorship then you are solely in charge.
If you are simply the caregiver, why do you not have a care contract for shared living expenses?

You have taken your father into your home.
At that point you have made it YOUR HOME.
You are an apparently unpaid slave as a caregiver while your brother holds the reins.

It is time to tell brother that you will be seeing an elder law attorney now to advise you on a care contract and/or placement.

Another way to go is to get together your docs who can write that you are not longer mentally or physically able to care for your father in home. Then a letter stipulating this goes from your attorney to the POA telling him how long he has to place his father.

See an attorney.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Because my brother is a greedy parasite who hates me.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to LaGorda58
Report

POA, Guardianship & Conservatorship are legal titles that come with legal terms.

Primary Caregiver is more of a social title I guess? While it can & should carry much respect & doesn't being much 'power'.

You have human rights to freedom.
No-one has the right, ever, to en-slave you.

In fact, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights explicitly references slavery, stating in Article 4: No one shall be held in slavery or servitude.

Therefore, as Primary Caregiver you may not have the power to transfer your Dad into a care home.. you don't have to continue to be his caregiver.

Does this make sense?
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Beatty
Report
LaGorda58 Jun 14, 2024
Yes it does.
(0)
Report
Your brother is the POA. You are the caregiver. You have done more than your share.

Tell your brother explicitly that you are giving notice as your father’s caregiver.

Whatever needs to be done to remove your father from your home, do it.

Your brother is POA, so it is his responsibility to figure it out.

Were you paid for your services or did your brother expect you to do everything for free? This is when I bet that you wish that you were an only child.

I hope that you will find a viable solution soon. I would ask your brother if he will be picking up your dad or if he needs you to drop him off.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to NeedHelpWithMom
Report
LaGorda58 Jun 14, 2024
You hit the nail right on the head with that one. YES. I do wish I was an only child, but not for inheritance reasons but just to be able to have our lives back without my brother and sister looming over us and calling the shots. TBH, I’d be ecstatic if Dad had no money. We have a bank account of dad’s that we use for his shopping and medical needs but that too is controlled by brother. But I can’t get government carer payments because he has too many assets. My brother gets to go on trips to Bali and Thailand with his new partner, living the life of Riley and earns over $200.000 a year, and then comes over to our home telling us that Dad would hate it in a nursing home. How would he know? It’s just another excuse not to spend any of the inheritance money putting Dad into care. It feels like a huge conspiracy.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
I call this *The Injury Test*.

What would happen if you broke your leg? Couldn't drive, just couldn't hobble around on crutches & look after your Father?

What would POA Brother likely do?

- Take your Father to his home?
- Hire Support Workers?
- Locate & pay for a bed for your Father in assisted living for respite (until you were able bodied again).

(Please don't break your leg to test this out!)

Basically, if you were UNABLE what then?

Next is *The Holiday Test*
You have every right to go on holiday btw. Whatever suits your inclinatuon & budget.

What if.. Hi Bro, just letting you know I'll be away in Sep on a 3 weeks Pacific Ocean cruise. Can't wait! So what care arrangements can we (as a family) make for Dad?

Lastly *The Quit Test*.
When a caregiver quits, the
care plan HAS to be changed.

Thoughts?

PS My Aged Care Plan.
Does Dad have one?
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Beatty
Report
LaGorda58 Jun 15, 2024
Actually, The broken leg option is funnier than you think. I am getting a long overdue knee replacement in August and will indeed be on crutches for 6 weeks. I was supposed to have this procedure a week ago but a bad UTI stopped that, so they rescheduled me for August. I had organised respite care but they were not satisfactory. So I have to go though another organisation now.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Ah, that little detail about you being in Australia would have been useful to mention since the term guardianship in America usually refers to having someone formally declared incompetent by the court.
Yours is a common problem when one person holds the purse strings and another is in charge of healthcare decisions. I think the resolution is in the understanding that having the authority to make decisions in no way obligates you to do any actual hands on caregiving, maybe it's time your father took a little vacation to visit your brother and his family for a few weeks, I like Beaty's suggestion of you taking your own holiday and being unavailable....
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to cwillie
Report
LaGorda58 Jun 22, 2024
Cwillie. You need some more fibre in your diet.
I have come on this forum to voice genuine concerns about my father and my siblings manipulating me into caring for my father indefinitely. Whether or not I initially stated that I am from Australia is of no consequence. However the Australian laws differ from USA regarding guardianship, the fact remains that I shouldn’t be made to look after a man who should be in permanent care.
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
My brother also wanted to protect his inheritance. He actually looked at Mom's money that way. ????? What I did was just tell my brother one day that I couldn't take care of her anymore, train any more caregivers to be there when I was at work, and that I had found a good assisted living place for her where I could still visit every day. I told him what it would cost Mom and could he come sign the papers? He did. He never visited her there and died a year before she died.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to ArtistDaughter
Report

I don't know your laws, but children withholding a parent's money needed for care is so common that I'm sure there is a way to take the POA away from your brother, or force him to pay a facility. Can you contact a lawyer? I would get your dad into a facility as soon as possible. They may even have advice for how to handle this.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Pressurized
Report

LaGorda, maybe we got sidetracked by the legal terms?

Rather than IF you can move your Father, have you already decided to? Have set the wheels in motion & seeking advice if Brother can stop you?
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Beatty
Report

In the replies below:
"I am getting a long overdue knee replacement in August and will indeed be on crutches for 6 weeks."

Choose a respite care home you like, close to your home if you can.

This is golden opportunity to change from 'respite care' to 'permanent care'.

Because if you are not wanting to take Dad back at the end of the respite stay, Dad's stay will need to be extended. Slightly or indefinitely.

POA Brother will need to sign the original admission papers for respite I guess? Will he?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Beatty
Report
LaGorda58 Jun 23, 2024
No
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
https://www.ag.gov.au/rights-and-protections/protecting-rights-older-australians

Give the hotline a call: 1800 353 374
(it's not a crises line so may be office hours)

I am thinking that witholding care (or funds to obtain care) could be considered *neglect* & therefore be *Elder Abuse* .

Ask for advice on this.

Has your Father had an Aged Care Needs Assessment? (Called ACAS or ACAT depending on state). If not, you can call your local council to arrange. A trained assessor will go through your Father's Dx, ADLs & care requirements. They may also be able to advice you of your next options. (I bet they have seen this before).
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Beatty
Report

Thanks to those of you who have given kind non judgemental advice. I will be leaving this forum now.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to LaGorda58
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter