I am sure some of you are caring for a loved one that used to be, still is and will always be very independent and who loves to exercise control. I am the daughter (only child) and the caregiver of a person like that, my mom.
She is declining and doesn’t have the ability to do half of what she used to do from a physical standpoint nor to handle basic things in life from an emotional standpoint. I am here, living with her to allow her to be in her house, to feel and be the lady of her house, but in order to help her while allowing her to be in her environment I have to run all errands as she cannot/does not want to go out, I give instructions to the helper we have because my mom is in bed most of the time; I give instructions to workers that come because she is not dealing with them, I help her solve any issues with her bank or credit cards -when she asks me to- because she cannot solve them.
Yet, my mom gets profoundly saddened and even offended, because she feels I am nullifying her, while I am from my heart only trying to help her. She cannot hear well what workers say (when she does deal with them) therefore she is not clear as to what she agreed to, when they finish their work and it is not what she wanted I’m the one blamed. I’m the one blamed for everything and I understand the underlying cause, I know her fight is not with me, it is with herself and it breaks my heart! I wish I could give her all my strength so she could be who she used to be and who she so desperately wants to be.
I am here with her to try to make her life a little easier and better, and so she doesn’t feel lonely and so she has someone that helps her to face the world with dignity, Yet I feel I’m not doing that at all, all the opposite my presence seems to mortify her...I cannot leave because she really is unable be by herself, and I would never do that. Plus she really doesn’t want me to leave, she would die from sadness if she was alone ( she used to live alone and that marked her deeply)
I recognize this is hurting me tremendously, I always have a knot in my stomach, always! Cannot sleep well, feel hopeless and powerless. I simply, honestly want to help my mom. I love her more than life itself, but it is so hard to be her daughter specially now. My mom is struggling with this stage of life more than she ever imagined and I never envisioned.
So, how do you help without hurting?
How do you support without our loved one feeling useless or as if we are intruding? I try my best to be kind and thoughtful but nothing seems to be enough.
How do you make your loved one feel loved, when you are taking on part of what they cannot do anymore?
How to love as your loved one needs to be loved at this stage of their life?
Struggling with patience and wisdom.
IMHO, I think it would be a good idea to “mirror” back what your mom says. Often, the elderly don’t feel heard or understood. When she makes comments, stop what you’re doing and ask her about it. Don’t interject. If she’s hesitating, then ask questions.
Mom; “I feel so useless.”
You; “Why do you feel that way?”
(Do NOT say “Oh NO you’re not!” You devalue her feelings by saying that.)
Mom; “Because I can’t do ......(a particular thing).”
You; “Yes, that must be frustrating.”
Mom; “I’ve done .......all my life and now I can’t. I feel helpless.”
You; “It must be hard to give up what you used to do and even harder to have someone else help. I know I’d have a hard time with that too.”
Mom; “It sure is!”
You; “Let’s focus on what you can do. You’re great at .......”
Mom; “Yes, I do that pretty well and these other things too.....”
In a perfect world, the conversation would go this way. If you can first acknowledge the problem, then sympathize with her, then redirect her to positive things, she may feel like she has been heard. Sometimes that’s all they need. It doesn’t hurt to find things she’s good at (crossword puzzles, cooking, sewing, etc.) and praise her when she completes them also. Lord knows how hard it is to decline and to watch your own limitations add up.
To lift her spirits, make sure she gets her hair done once in awhile or gets a new outfit here and there, fresh flowers for the table or something that would brighten her day.
Lastly, throw your guilt out the window. You are doing everything you can. I can “see” the love you have for your mother in your words. 🥰 Whether she can accept it, appreciate it or respond to it, she knows it too. Hopefully that and the strength of the Lord will see you through. (We’ll be here for you too!)
Tell yourself daily, “I’m doing the best I can. I can control and am responsible for MY emotions but I can’t control nor be responsible for the emotions of others.”
God bless you both.
It’s truly difficult. Yes, it is a burden, a huge weight on our shoulders but the last thing I want my mom to feel is being a burden to me. I know she feels this way at times. She even says that once in awhile and it breaks my heart.
I wish I had a good answer for you. All I can do is offer my support as another caregiver. I feel exactly as you do. It is extremely difficult to see our loved one deteriorating. They feel useless and we feel helpless.
Many, many hugs!!!
I pray for you and all caregivers as this job is so hard, exhausting, heartbreaking and very challenging at times. Your mom is very fortunate to have such a loving daughter! ❤️❤️
I will share something that I know for anyone that is not me -because I live it- may be funny. Yesterday I was asking my mom if she wanted a latte or just soy milk, I said it once, she looked at me as if I was speaking Chinese, meaning she didn’t hear me; so I said it again, still the look on her face was indicating she didn’t hear me, so I said it the third time louder...she heard me, but now the look on her face was of annoyance, being deeply hurt and mistreated by me, because by raising my voice I’m humiliating her, making her feel as if she is unable to hear (which is true, she cannot hear well, but I try not to make it obvious since she doesn’t want to wear an hearing aid). I swear my intention was FAR from making her feel bad, or showing her that I was “mad because she couldn’t hear me” as in being impatient. None of that from the bottom of my heart. All I was trying to do was to find out if she wanted a latte or just milk.
These days she finds everything I do or not do as me looking down on her because of her declining, she is consistently mad, sad and offended. It is so terribly hard to handle the situation because all I am hoping to do is all the opposite of what she thinks. Being mistreated by me is so not what is happening and it breaks my heart and yes, my patience, to see her hurting for something that is not happening.
She even said to me yesterday that she was never able to cry, however the other day she was crying, she said. And she meant she was crying because of how she feels she is being treated. That really breaks my heart but also frustrates me because I know I’m not living in a parallel world where I am not conscious of how I behave and how I treat her, I also know though that my physical and mental and even spiritual health are hurting because of this.
Such a hard journey, isn’t it? You had to step back, yet I don’t think I can do more stepping back than what I’m currently doing, yet that is also seen as an “I’m tired” behavior. For believers like me, the help from above is ALL that pushes us, and I constantly ask for enlightenment and guide through this, to know how to be the daughter my mom needs at his point in her life.
You likely have it harder than me because it is not only your mom, but your sibling who requires or will require your care too. May God bless you, and guide you as well!
We don’t see eye to eye on anything. If I don’t do what she says there will be an argument and believe me I don’t do well arguing, I never win anyway. We use to be best friends. Now we are so far apart I don’t think our relationship has a chance to recover. I know you ask, why do I let her take control? I’ve always been a people pleaser. I felt if their happy I’m happy. I’m so far from happy
( stressed, anexity attacks, etc )
My advise, step back and give her the space she wants. Get her the help she needs to take care of her and keeping her safe. I wouldn’t want you to go through what I am. Be there as the loving daughter and let her know how much you love her and you will be both happy and continue having a loving daughter and Mother relationship.
God Bless you and I hope what ever you decide to do keeps an open and loving relationship with your mom
Isn’t it sad how caregiving changes the dynamics of a relationship? I care for my mom. My brothers do nothing to help. They always want to tell me what to do. I have tried to call you explain how things are since I am here day to day. I don’t care how smart your daughter is, and I am sure she is, not insulting your daughter in any way but you should be respected as the one who is there handling all of the day to day things. You have experience that she may not have, even if she is a nurse. Hugs!
but exercising control can be a nice way of saying manipulation.
My mother is very similar and rants at us but is charming to the AL staff. Sometimes you both need that distance. Her for the care she needs , you for the sanity.
And your mother knows somewhere inside all your love to help her is why you do what you do. Just be good to yourself, as well.
A therapist told me that I was taking my mom's power (in a manner of speaking) away when I just outright did things. I thought it was making her feel better when in fact it was my way of trying to assuage my anxiety. Because my mom has more capability now, I just let her tell me what she can't do, and I have definitely sniffed out what can do but still asks me to do anyways. "Give it a try mom," is my new phrase. She doesn't necessarily like it but sometimes, what do you know, it gets done...
Above all else, you're doing your absolute best in a tough situation. I hope you surround yourself in that knowledge, you have nothing to feel guilty about or regret. Everything you are doing comes from a good place, even though the response you get may not appear that way. It is.
Also she was very mean to my dad but when he’d leave she would be incredibly concerned with him not being there, and worried about him being out by himself. She cared about and loved him even though she didn’t show it.
When she fell and had home health come in, it would depend on the aide they sent. One aide wasn’t a good fit, was on phone, left mom alone. I requested they didn’t send her anymore. The other aide did a great job.
Home health is over. I enjoyed the break of bathing her when I had it though. Mom has adjusted to me doing it for her. I think it’s hard to allow children to help in bathing at first. I get that.
If your mother has Medicare, it covers in-home hospice nursing and bathing assistance at 100% if your mother has enough medical issues. You can check the reviews of hospice agencies in your zip code on medicare.gov/hospicecompare. Agencies are very helpful on the phone and offer one free consultation visit if you want to explore this option. Many people think that they are only for care in final days, but they can re-certify patients every 6 months & I know of cases that have been covered for a couple of years. The hospice team consists of a physician, RN, social worker, aides, Chaplain-all trained on the needs of the elderly at this stage of life. They support the caregiver as well as the patient. Sometimes, the patient can absorb information from an objective medical person much better than from a family member.
Wishing you peace and support in this chapter of your life. Your mother may never be able to show appreciation for the care and love that you are offering to her, but you will know in your heart all the good that you have done.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ek04qjT-xQ
Thank you for sharin the Teepa video : )
That is okay. It is a valid response. She is frustrated, angered and saddened by the loss of her abilities.
One thing you can do is really accept her right to do this. You say you know her fight is not with you, it's with herself; but do you apply that "head" knowledge to how you feel when she is in mid-fight? There are tricks of the trade when it comes to this kind of detachment: do you use any psychological tools, do you mind if I ask?
You can also be alert to avoidable small irritations and discourtesies - such as people talking over her head about her business when she is right there in the room - and challenge them.
When it comes to carrying out tasks on your mother's behalf, I'd spend less time on being kind and thoughtful about it, more on being matter-of-fact. We all wish she was fine and didn't need help. Fact is, she does. There it is. So let's get the job done and not dwell on who's done it. Be careful that explanations and tiptoeing around don't rub it in that she can't manage, when what you want to do is to spare her pain.
This is *hard*. You love your mother, and what she's going through is hard for you to witness. You do know you're allowed to be unhappy about that, yes?
I do remember wondering from the beginning, and I still wonder, whether your being with your mother in this way was a good decision. But it's a bit late for that, and besides - there it is, and here we are. So. What are you doing to strengthen whatever supports you?
I think we all wish to spend our last days with “dignity”, but sadly our physical and mental limitations sometimes dictate otherwise. For both your and mom’s sake it might be time to consider long term living arrangements. I know you feel this is against her wishes, but maintaining a home when health is declining can be extremely difficult and a burden. This would at least allow you to spend quality time with your beloved mother. So much pressure would be off and you could concentrate on what means most.....being with her without all the other distractions...allowing some dignity for both of you. And please, recognize your own limitations. Keep us posted. Best to you and mom.
First of all let me say that you have a heart of gold and your mother is very blessed to have you. Your mother needs a great deal of help and you have selflessly stepped in to take care of things. It is common for caregivers to forget about their own needs. You sound exhausted and overwhelmed. You mention that you have help but did not go into detail about what kind of help. It is sufficient? Would you benefit from having additional help to relieve some of the stress?
Are you planing to stay with your mother until the end of her life or are you making further arrangements for her outside of her home? Do you have any healthcare in your home, home health, hospice, etc?
I hope that you know you are doing everything that you possibly can and even though you feel that she is not trying to be hurtful to you by blaming you if something doesn't get done, it still hurts. Sometimes it is the pain talking, it is the disease or illness talking. They are not the people they once were and you are very understanding and compassionate to realize that.
Please take care of yourself. It isn't selfish to fulfill your own needs too. Can you or do you want to speak to your mom about certain issues? You spoke here with enormous love and respect. Is that possible to convey the same message to her? Would she understand?
Let us know how you are doing. We are here for you to ask questions or simply vent. Take care.
All is part of the control issue that made this question arise.
An yes, I am here to stay with my mom indefinitely. It is the best “solution” in our case, and trust me I feel blessed to be able to be doing what I am doing, I just hope I receive the wisdom to do and say what is right, at the right moment.
Thank you so much!
PS Please take care of yourself. Get out and do something to make you happy. That knot in your stomach isn't good and you know it.
As to your original question, I think that is a journey for all of us. No one size fits.
I was a lurker here for several years prior to,posting. I read some post about someone's bowel movement, which could not be expelled completely. That person, the caregiver, uh,helped, digitally.no can do. No. No.
Dignity and ALZ kinda go,by wayside, imo.
but I have the blessing of being able to maintain some joy in my heart most of my days, and I don’t take that blessing lightly because we all know in our caregiving journey joy is hard to keep in our hearts many times. My mom’s mental health is the one severely hurting, between deep depression and so many other conflicts, hence I positioned this question under mental health.
thank you!