Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
You tell HER when she calls, just this. Read it to her in fact. It's perfect. It admits that you have limitations and aren't perfect, and know how you can be sometimes, but don't have the power to change some of it. That you treasure her and hope your relationship will survive. I can't imagine much else you can do until you perhaps decide that doing this care for your father is finally becoming too much for you, that it is destroying your relationships and you are too overwhelmed to continue it hands on. That realization and time may come, and it may not. I sure do wish you the best.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My husband thrives on these dynamics with his family. I keep telling him no one has any business questioning the sister who's doing it all. But they've all always enjoyed trashing each other...
Dealing with my parents/estate has actually brought my sister and I closer together--though there's that occasional day when we each want to strangle each other. Our brother...Who? He's been MIA for years--then tried to swoop in when our mom was dying and told Hospice he was "nursing her." Umm...who are you again?
Best part was when funeral home guy tried to deal with our brother (I'm executor, was POA) while my sister and I were in the same room. Better believe I shut that down damn fast. (Actually, my sister is now a family legend for throwing him out of the house because of that Hospice incident.) My brother and I had a chance to chat non-parents while waiting to sign papers at the funeral home later. It's fine or fine enough. But as my sister and I have been cleaning out house, listing it, paying bills...we haven't heard from him once. When our dad first died, we got tired of complaining about our brother so we gave him some things we needed him to do when he could. He never did any of them.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I had the same issue with my brother. I took care of mom long distance for about 5 years and then she moved in with me for the last 5 years of her life. My brother saw her about 4 times in the last 5 years. In fact he saw her only once in 3 years just weeks before she died. I was very bitter. I ended up avoiding him completely. I was afraid of what I would say. Afraid I would say something I would regret later.

When I placed mom in an ALF, I called and told him he needed to fund what Medicaid would not pay. He agreed but never had to help since she died before it was needed,

I will not go into his excuses. They were weak at best. The last visit he made I was able to speak openly about my resentment. Not surprising, he actually believed he was helping (sending chocolates every couple of months).

However, once my mom died, we did come to some type of equilibrium. He acknowledged my sacrifice. He admitted he did nothing. That has helped me get past the resentment. We actually have a fragile new relationship that I hope will heal over time.

I still feel cheated but, now that mom is gone, he is the last connection to my family. I want to make it work. It will take time and will mostly likely be different than it could have been.

When you are a caregiver your entire life is surrounded by that duty. Once that caregiving time has ended, at least for me, I wanted “normal” and normal meant creating that sibling connection again.

Perhaps you are stronger than I, but it was difficult for me to forgive and forget when I was in the middle of the caregiving duties.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
CTTN55 Feb 2023
I fully understand the resentment at do-nothing siblings. In my case, my 3 brothers were all out of state. One went years between visits, and another one was retired and should have come down more than he did. The third came down when he could (which I appreciated).

Although I didn't live with my mother, she demanded more and more of my time (even though I set strict limits). She tried to get me to do Internet research for her obsessions. I refused. She got one of my brothers to do it. When I suggested that another brother do something she was demanding of me, she flew off the handle, telling me that MY time wasn't valuable like my brother's was.

After she was hospitalized for a gallbladder infection, then went to rehab, then to LTC, I requested compensation for all the hours. The main POA brother was the one who came down most often, and he understood what I was going through. He agreed, and also offered to compensate me for the past caregiving. The other two brothers didn't put up a fuss (although the one who was least involved wanted me to wait until the trust settlement after my mother died -- I said no. I knew the trust stated that any beneficiary who tried to get more than their 1/4 split would get nothing). When I brought up compensation to my mother earlier, she hissed at me, "You don't pay FAMILY!"

So I got paid $20/hour. The pay went a long way towards easing my resentment, as I could consider the hours spent as a job. It was all gifted to me, and because my mother would never become Medicaid-eligible, I had to pay no taxes on it.

This obviously wouldn't work for everyone. I was one daughter who refused to put up with the unequal distribution of caregiving that so many daughters allow to happen.

BTW, I set up from the beginning of the more intense caregiving (basically when my mother gave up driving at age 90 and I had to become her driver and thus had to spend a lot more time with her) that I might want compensation at some point. I emailed my brothers once a week, letting them know what I did for our mother, how much time it took, what she was like, etc. So none of them could claim to be surprised at what was going on (particularly the two who rarely came down to see her).
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Yes…very tough. My brother and I fell apart during this also..I decided it had to stop and I changed me. We opened up, talked about mom issues, past family issues and agreed to agree on some stuff and not to agree on other things. Counseling has opened up how I view the world these days. Well worth the small cost. Ps: I still do the bulk of the work but peace is worth it.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Davenport Feb 2023
Counseling during my caregiving time (including in regard to the stress it created among my sibs) helped me keep my sanity. And this forum!
(2)
Report
You can’t manage that really. Tell Sis to step in a little so she can 1. Know what it’s like, & 2.put up or shut up. Tolerate no disrespect & tell her to contribute or butt out. And hire for the extra you can’t manage, if possible. One CANNOT do it all and, for the sake of all concerned, should not!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

That stinks, I'm sorry about that. I don't have an answer. At least, you do have someone in regards to a relative who parrots 🦜 your dad's complaints, that means they are talking. Maybe if you get an answer, it might help me with my problem.

My mom is late stages dementia. Her youngest son my younger brother just wiped his hands of anything to do with her, my mom his mom lives with me, I am the primary health caregiver to her. I do everything. He don't even call me or her or visit me or her, he lives one mile down the road. So he wiped his hands of me as well. He and I were very close now we don't exist.

So how will that relationship be pieced back together?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Dad has a Dementia according to your profile. I guess your sister does not understand what that means. For one, they become like children. He may not be so much pitting you against each other. But like a small child not getting their way he whines to sister.

You may want to consider putting Dad in Memory care if he can afford it. Or a nice Long-term care facility on Medicaid if he can't. His care is going to be more and more as his Dementia progresses. The sooner you place him, the sooner he adjusts.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Maybe you can tell her how much you enjoyed talking with her, and how you miss your old dynamic. Tell her that Dad seems to enjoy pitting you both against each other, and you'd rather not. You're doing your best, and without her seeing firsthand how hard that is, her perspective is different. Ask her to schedule some time so you can get away. If she won't do that, then suggest you don't talk about Dad…you won't complain about how hard it is, and she won't criticize you about something she hasn't seen firsthand.

My mom used to try to pit my sister and me against each other. When we had a conversation about it, we agreed that we'd discount anything negative she says (usually about me, the caregiver/chaperone) and talk only to each other when information was needed. It worked like a charm, and we've been incredibly close for many years…simply because we cut out the middle man.

Good luck!
Helpful Answer (14)
Report

Why not plan a long vacation and ask your sister to come stay with your Dad for at least 2 weeks? Once she's exposed to the daily reality of his caregiving her eyes will be opened. There's nothing like a good object lesson to speak volumes for your situation.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter