Follow
Share

I wonder how many caregivers think, their situation is a punishment from God.

Find Care & Housing
No It Is part of the circle of Life , we all die .
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to KNance72
Report

I agree it FEELS LIKE punishment from God when you reach those totally exasperated times...but in reality, usually being too nice got you stuck in a dark place. Your profile tells a long and difficult journey.

Caregiving for 18 years is soul crushing.
Time to place your husband and get your life back, instead of want to end it.
Wishing you strength and courage,
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Dawn88
Report

My father is in a NH and mom is now gone and I am going back and forth and it is mostly my choice.

It is a different set of concerns at the NH from when my parents were home. Here you need to be sure his needs are being met consistently and advocate if you don’t like something. . I am just grateful I don’t have to cobble together 24/7 care and I am not bathing or toileting my father.

I am grateful for what we have in place for him at this facility because it would be a hell of a lot worse if he were home.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

At home caregiving is a choice. As such, it's not a punishment from God, and certainly not to you, who can choose to place your husband in managed care if you're at the point of collapse. This is the free will we're given.

What choices can you make now to lessen your burden and free you up a bit? Help you get the well deserved rest you need? Do consider in home help, at a minimum, so your entire life isn't devoted to caregiving.

Best of luck to you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

It’s not a punishment from God .

It’s the unfortunate price we are paying for people in general living longer in a dependent state of needing care .

All I’ve gotten out of it is fear that I may lose my mind to dementia and drive my children crazy . I don’t want them to go through what I did .
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
ElizabethAR37 Aug 12, 2024
Yes, that's true. Longevity in and of itself is NOT the be-all and end-all, IMO. What's the point of continuing to exist in a dependent state while draining one's family of energy, joy and possibly $$$ they will need for their own elder years?
(2)
Report
If your God is a punishing God I am terribly sorry for your choice in gods. I would search out a kinder god. Not that I think your question is unusual. As an RN I saw parents loose perfectly BEAUTIFUL innocent little babies to brain tumors, leukemia, et al. Imagine THEIR problems with THEIR gods, if you will? We have then Roger Rosenblatt--that very kindest of men- who wrote of completely losing his strong faith upon the sudden death of his marvelous daughter. I am an atheist, actually, so I've no one to blame for the many trials and losses we encounter in life; I consider that a "blessing", if you will.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
ElizabethAR37 Aug 12, 2024
Agreed from a fellow atheist (atheist-leaning agnostic to be strictly accurate). I don't buy that any god--if there is one--cares much what happens to me, so that makes me responsible. And when I make my Final Exit, I'm gone. That's it. I have no problem with that.
(3)
Report
I don't necessarily think it's punishment from God, OTOH I don't see it as an "honor" or that I'm deriving anything positive from it. Most days it's meh, some days it awful, and other days it's scream in the night, hair on fire misery.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Tynagh
Report

I understand the exhaustion and the mental load. And no one can understand unless they’ve been in this situation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Alyson
Report

I always wondered what I was suppose to learn from this experience. I did not learn patience thats for sure. I learned my limitations. Learned I am not a caregiver. I don't believe God gives us only what we can handle. I know people who have so much on their plate its mind boggling. Others, have never experienced what I have. My in-laws have never had children or animals. They never took care of their parents. Because they moved states away, they have never had to drive anyone to appts, get a phone call in the middle of the night about parent being taken to the hospital and you needing to be there because they have Dementia. They have been married 56 years with no major illnesses. They worked and retired. They are generous but also used to being just the 2 of them.

My Mom used to say "God allows things to happen". He never promised us life would not be hard at times.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

My only concern here is you because as you said in your profile if it wasn't for your son living with you, you would kill yourself. That is a very scary place to be and I hope and pray that you'll reach out to the Suicide Hotline at 988.
It sounds like you've reached the breaking point and that it's time to make some major changes in your husbands care. So I hope you'll start looking into placing him in the appropriate facility where you can get back to just being his wife and advocate and not his burned out caregiver who wants to kill herself because she's so overwhelmed.

My late husband had a massive stroke at the age of 48(a year and a half after we were married)which left him unable to walk, talk, read, write and paralyzed on his right side.
Our lives were turned completely upside down. Now my husband did relearn how to walk again with a brace on his leg, but his speech only returned slightly and he was never able to use his right arm, or read or write again.
He then developed seizures caused by the damage done to his brain by the stroke, and had many ongoing health issues, including developing vascular dementia towards the end of his life.
It was a constant rollercoaster that we were on until my husbands death at the age of 72, and had it not been for my faith and my caregiver support group, I wouldn't have made it.
And I can tell you that with everything that I went through in my life and with my husband that it has made me a much stronger person, and for that I am grateful and give all the glory to God.

God loves you and doesn't want to punish you. He wants you to seek His face and trust that He will guide you with what needs to be done next. You just have to ask.
But from what you've said in your profile, it definitely sounds like your husband needs to be placed in a facility. And if money is an issue you can apply for Medicaid. There is help out there for not only your husband but for you as well.
I wish you well in finding it.
God bless you.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report
Anxietynacy Aug 12, 2024
Funky, I didn't read there profile, I'm so use to people not filling it out I have up. Good advice!
(1)
Report
I just read your story. My father had a major stroke as well many, many years ago. He did well for a very long time until he started declining a few years ago. When my mom passed away many years ago, I stepped in to help him. Long story short, it became too difficult . There were falls and hospitalizations. I did the best I could. We struggled to get to doctor's appointments and etc. He refused to wear pullups at first so I had to change sheets daily and on top of all of that, my childhood was full of emotional abuse towards my mom and I. He is now in a facility after a long hard process. Is it possible for your husband to go to a facility? It sounds like it would be the best thing. Prayers to you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to faithfulbeauty
Report

I cannot believe that anyone sane thinks that difficult caregiving is a ‘punishment from God’. They certainly haven’t been reading their Bible.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
waytomisery Aug 12, 2024
I was kidding . For some reason, I thought of how many sets of angel wings I would have if it were true . I apologize if I offended anyone .
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
My non-religious, uninvolved brother tells me I am “earning my wings” by helping my mentally ill narcissist mother. I am also not religious, so I don’t find his statement helpful. I do think hard caregiving situations are a combination of many things, bad timing, financial issues, family dynamics, the messed up US healthcare system, being at the mercy of either a mentally ill elder or someone with dementia who never got a POA assigned when they still could etc.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Oedgar23
Report

I’ve never believed caregiving comes about as a punishment. To me, it’s simply a life circumstance like any other. There are trials, rewards, and lessons in it as there are in so many things
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

Ha! Why wouldn’t a just God get the punishment over with a merciful lightning strike or maybe a heart attack? What’s with this five years of changing Depends and pushing them around in wheelchairs?
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
waytomisery Aug 11, 2024
To earn our wings I suppose .
For some reason God thinks I need more than one pair of wings . 🤔🤔🤔
(6)
Report
Reba, you are being perfected through this hard trial and I am sure it feels like punishment.

I pray that you find peace, comfort and strength for your trial in caring for your husband.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Isthisrealyreal
Report

Huh, no I never did, but now I am
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Anxietynacy
Report
Anxietynacy Aug 11, 2024
Sorry if that sounded rude, it literally was my first thought. But honestly no you should never think that. Give us more information we might be able to help you sort things out
(0)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter