Follow
Share

My grandmother has 5 children, 15 grandchildren, good financial resources and her home is that gathering place for our whole family, my cousins come through to stay a few day routinely, some every few weeks, some a few times a year. Two of her children live nearby and visit routinely, and my aunt lives 5 hours away but will come and stay for a week or weekend every few months.
My sister and I have lived with my grandmother on and off for most of our adult life (I am 27,) and the care that my sister and I have provided has given my grandmother a very smooth transitions from independent adult to dependent senior. It has worked well for all of us, my grandmother got loving care and company (her husband, my grandfather, died over 40 years ago, when the kids were very young) and my sister and I had a home base while we were in school, sorting out early relationships, etc. But in the last year I have finished nursing school, and my grandmother's needs have intensified, and her mood has darkened. She is unhappy with all the food brought into the house and cannot/will not understand that she is no longer capable of cooking for herself (she is physically weak from arthritis, and is very forgetful and easily confused.) She complains that she is lonely when no one is visiting and that people are to noisy and disorganized when her family is around, she is insulting to some of my cousins and their spouses, calling them fat and sneering about them behind their backs, these judgments are not out or character, but she is so much less subtle and no longer expresses any regret or caution when she say such mean things. I feel like my love for her is being pushed to the breaking point, I desperately want to move out and start my own life, my sister needs to focus on her new marriage and career, and my mother and aunt are also busy, enjoying post child freedom, starting new jobs and projects. My mother has hired I house keeper to come in two morning a week, and she is working out well, but the implications of this have upset my grandmother, as has my request that my uncle come and cook dinner every sunday. I feel like my grandmother's decline must be due in part to my impending departure, and as I have no marriage planned, do not plan to have children, start a family etc, that it is foolish of me to place my meager life plans (live alone and knit and garden a lot) ahead of maintaing maximum stability for her in the last years of her life.
Aside from arthritis and increasing confusion and memory problems she is in good health, and could live for another decade. I feel like at the end of that time I would be a shell of my self and my life would have passed me by.
I want to be able to go visit my boyfriend with out having to notify my mother/sister. I want to enjoy the dinner I've cooked without someone complaining about it, I want to plant a garden without someone coming along behind me and removing my labels and planting on top of what I have planted, and I want to invite my BF over and have some privacy, without family likely to drop by at any time and without having interrupt our evening at 9pm to check if grandma has taken her meds.
Mostly I just want some time alone, and not have to listen to her litany of worries and complaints (the same every day) after I get home form work. And I want to enjoy her company again, she used to be such a wonderful woman.
What should I do?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

26 Answers

Most
Helpful Newest
First Oldest
First
Your grandmother is fortunate that she's been able to stay in her own home and have the companionship and care that your sister and you have provided for so long. However, with her diminishing conditions, I think it's finally time that her children step up to the plate and assume their responsibility to their mother. They need to come to terms on how her care will be handled and take you and your sister out of the equation. As hard-hearted as this may sound, It is a responsibility that they need to assume. I have a similar situation that involves siblings that claim that they don't have much time in their busy lives and cannot share much of the responsibility of caring for our elderly parent. Putting your life on hold and not pursuing the normal things a 27 year old could possibly cause you to miss out on opportunities and may lead to bitterness. I don't think it's unreasonable that her kids provide the assistence she needs.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
the saddest part of my situation is that this is my husbands step-mother. She has been married to his dad for 23 years. They married 3 years before we did. MIL has no family and no one will take care of her. I promised her years ago that I would't let his step children take advantage of her and she is staying with us, as she should have been. No one has offered help to us and no one calls her either. She is now at the end, as i have hospice coming in now to help w/her. It is sad to me, coming from a large family, that this woman has no one who cares about her except my husband and I.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I have taken care of my mother in my home for eleven years, and in that time my husband died. I also took care of my autistic brother for the same amount of time, as my mom could no longer do it. My brother was diagnosed with cancer and given 6 to 9 months to live. Treatment was not an option. Hospice advised me to move my mother as my brother needed me more right now, and found a wonderful foster home for her about 20 minutes away. I moved her there and took my brother on a dream vacation to Hawaii for 10 days. He died approximately 2 weeks after we returned. It hit me hard as we are 1 year apart and he was 61!!! The downside for me now is I am now faced with moving on alone and am trying to figure out what to do with myself. When you have lived serving others and never putting yourself first, you don't have the hobbies or friends you will need to sustain your golden years. If you are young (under 50) don't make the same mistakes I did. Your grandmother had a full life, now it's your turn. Live your life and visit her once a month.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
@ Karentaylor, OP here
My condolences on your loss, and my thanks for sharing such a recent loss. Your home must feel so empty with her gone.
It is this sudden end, in part, that makes me want a little distance, when she is gone I want to remember her whole life (or the last 27 years anyway) that I got to be a part of, and I want to do it in a place where I will not be crushed by the absence of her wandering, bitter, final incarnation.
and before her passing I want to be some one she is happy to see again, rather then the chiding task mistress I must now be so much of the time.
again, my condolences, remember your love for her, your love that was expressed every time you used a fantasy of escape to get you through another day caring for her when she needed you. Bless you and be well.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
I totally disagree with darleeng096 because Thyme is a granddaughter and her sister. They are young women and need to live their own lives. They have already done much more than any grandchildren I know. IT IS THE poor Grandmother's CHILDRENS PLACE TO TAKE CARE OF THEIR OWN MOTHER. What the hell is wrong with them? Very selfish of them. Grandaughters PLEASE go and leave it with her own children. Then you and visit as you are able and I know you love her dearly. I have helped 2 days a week with my bedridden mother for 3 1/2 years along with my wonderful stepfather of 16 yrs, who is now 92. I know how you girls feel. I was there for my mother untill this past Dec when she passed. I out of 3 other siblings have been the ONE.I never regreted a moment because she was my Mother ( not a grandmother ). I also took my disabled brother 68 in for past 3 yrs now. I am so tired and fried because he has 3 grown children and not one has been here except one and only one time. I have to get my life back now while I am still healthy. A parent and child is one thing normal to stand by each other but all the rest is bs. Not fair period, no matter how much we love family members. Do not feel quilty, its your parents responsibility!!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
I wanted all those things, too. I saw others with "normal" family lives and envied them. Mom died suddenly last Sunday. Now, I'd give ANYTHING to have her and all her complaints back again. I have only sorrow and regret for wishing for that "normal" life I so coveted. Each case is different, each individual unique in his/her own way. But one thing we don't know is when our loved one will go. For many of us, unfortunately, it's sudden and totally unexpected. Maybe some kind of compromise with her would work or maybe even a gradual change in living arrangements. Seniors don't take well to sudden changes. I would plant ornamental sweet potato (lime green) and grow it in a mound. Mom would get it in her head that sweet potato had no business in a flower bed and I'd go out and find where she had pulled it all up. She de-frocked the Christmas tree daily. It blocked her view. We generally got a good laugh out of these things - but then there were other things that annoyed me greatly. I'd gladly take them all back, though. I had no idea how lonely I'd be without her. I told people how I worshipped solitude; now I detest it. As caregivers we should always remember to validate our loved one's worth, impress upon them how very much they are loved, and let them know that they will not be left alone, especially at the end. Holding my mom as she drew her last breath was the most horrific, yet cherished moment of my life.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
elderly people do not realize that you need to have a life of your own. they are only thinking of what is happening to them. they want you to be as miserable as they are. they do no realize what they are doing to your life. only what you can do for them. life is short and you better enjoy it while you can. they have lived their lives but you still are young and you owe it to yourself to enjoy it.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
elderly people do not realize that you need to have a life of your own. they are only thinking of what is happening to them. they want you to be as miserable as they are. they do no realize what they are doing to your life. only what you can do for them. life is short and you better enjoy it while you can. they have lived their lives but you still are young and you owe it to yourself to enjoy it.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
I am taking care of my father with the help of caregivers and slowly we are transitioning to all caregivers. The transition phase is the most difficult especially when your grandmother is cognitively declining which it sounds like is occurring. Just know that the transition phase is difficult and hire a company that provides consistent caregiving including assistance with dressing, food preparation and basic housecleaning. Relationships develop slowly. It is not fun to live with resentment. Over time your grandmother will thank you especially if you come to visit her regularly or perhaps get all of your relatives on a schedule so you share the burden. It is easier for your grandmother to have only a few people in at a time so spread the visits out. I encourage you to create your own life in your own space and know that you are doing this with love, compassion for yourself and your grandmother.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I didnt LIVE with mine. The family sent her to me for 3 years. Put a Note on her Back and put her on the plane " RETURN TO SENDER".
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
My heart goes out to you. You are young and have done what you could, but I don't think it's unfair of you to want your own life. I think it's time for others to step up and take some responsibility. I am a little over 7 years into taking care of my mother, a stroke survivor, but I am her only child and I don't regret any of the time that I've spent taking care of her. I would be lying if I said I am thriving, though...I am near exhaustion at times..and at other times, feel completely overwhelmed. But, taking it all into consideration, I wouldn't have had it any other way. I love her dearly and wish I could give her the health and the quality of life that she deserves, but I am limited in the fact that I am one person...not trained medically, and I am tired. I don't want to have any regrets, though, when her time comes...so I keep plugging away at it. I've taken to writing my feelings down...trying to cope. Good luck to you...I hope that the other's take over and give you some much needed time to yourself.
Caregiver's Lament

I'd like to set aside a minute,
To see if there is pleasure in it...
To take a cleansing breath so deep,
That I'll forget my lack of sleep.
I'd like to set aside an hour,
To prune a shrub, to plant a flower...
To find a hidden shady nook,
Where I could sit and read a book.
I'd like to set aside a day,
To give myself some time to play...
To take a stroll around the park,
To linger out, way after dark.
I'd like to set aside some time,
To paint a picture, pen a rhyme...
Regain a bit of sweet control,
To do those things that soothe my soul.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
OP here,
thanks to everyone for your answers, all gave me some much needed perspective, from others who are also caregivers, something I've been feeling a lack of. Particularly helpful was the question of weather or not would would want to leave if my grandmother's moods had not become so difficult. hearing this reminded me that I have planned to move upon graduation since I first moved in, and also that my grandmother has in that past been very consistent in saying that this arrangement will only last as long as it is beneficial to both of us.
I was feeling quite lost when I wrote this question, and the intervening days, conversations with a few family members and all your thoughtful answers have made me feel on firmer ground.
So as soon as I find a position that allows me to do so I will be moving out, and my aunts and uncles will have full opportunity to benefit from the growth experience that is care giving.
Also, thanks to the people who mentioned that a simpler existence might be less upsetting for Grandma, I'm not sure how this would be implemented in my family, but it is an important thought, that the warm but sometimes loud and chaotic bosom of family may not be the best place to live at 90.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Let me see if I understand this correctly. Your mom and her sister are enjoying a life without children at home while you are at home with grandmother as if you would never have any desire to get married or have a family of your own? That sounds like you are the chosen one being kept in line with a lot of fear, obligation and guilt coming either from grandmother, mother or both? At 27 with a nursing degree and a boyfriend, you don't have many years left to start a family. I think it is high time to fly this nest before it becomes your grave. Life is not all about grandmother. You have a life also and your mother and her sister have some responsibilities to tend to as well instead of using you as their convenient servant.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
I know you love her very much but remember what you are instructed to do in an airplane when there is an emergency: put the oxygen mask over your own face first and then help your dependent. Your family will put an alternate plan in place and you will be part of it. However, you won't be giving up your whole life to her and you'll find that you actually enjoy being with her again when it's in more limited doses. You'll also have more energy to help solve the problems. She may need a more simple living environment with less variables since everything affects her negatively. Also, she may need anti-depression meds. My wonderful father grew unbearable to be around until he entered (involuntarily) assisted living with dementia care. After a 9 month transition he started to thrive because his life was simpler. Anti-depression meds made him fun to be with again. The family takes turns taking him out about 5 days a week and he stays for hours at our houses. He's integrated into the family but has a life that his diminishing energy and mental capacity can handle. I wish you much luck at this difficult time.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Thyme, you'll have to consult your personal conscience, but in my world I have stringent requirements in order for something to qualify for guilt feelings:

An actiion intended to harm others, or without regard to the harm it may cause others.

That's it. No harm, no guilt.

Here are things that should generate guilt feelings:
robbing a bank
cursing the postman because all you got was bills
knocking down a little old lady and grabbing her purse
cheating on your income taxes (making others pay your share)
using the last of the toilet paper and not replacing the role
running out on someone who is depending on you (boss, roommate, etc.) without adequate notice or preparation

So, if I were in your spot, the question my conscience would be asking me, is "are you doing this to harm Grandma? Have you taken the steps you can to prevent or mitigate any unintentional harm?"

Getting on with your own life is not in the same category as stealing money out of your motehr's purse, at least by my ethical standards. You have to consult your own standards.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Absolutely lose the guilt. I do wonder if grandma has been diagnosed or is being treated for anything. My mom's temperament has improved greatly this year partly, I believe, because of a med. and partly because of how Dad and I talk with her (we don't argue or try to 'orient' her into reality anymore). But I am not saying it is your responsibility to pursue such diagnosis and treatment, Thyme. You have done a lot for one so young and so busy. Even if Grandma were not as grouchy, you would be needing your freedom (i.e., able to go and do things without having to report to someone where you're going and what you're doing). It sounds as if you have a big family, and that if everyone would step up, the load would not be too great on any individual. Helping that happen, though, is another thing altogether. It seems reasonable that you tell folks you're moving out and maybe (MAYBE, if you want to) you will take a shift once a week (or twice a month or whatever you are willing to do) with Grandma. Good luck. Live your life.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Absolutely, and the longer YOU take care of her, the longer everyone else in the family will LET you. No one helps us at all. Take care of yourself. The stress is enought to take you under, much less just trying to take care of them. I finally demanded that we get a nurse to come in while I was at work. We need one now through the night as MIL keeps everyone up due to screaming and kicking. It is really an awful disease. All of this is starting to affect my family and if MIL is still hanging on after the holidays she will be going to a home. What is boils down to is that no one wants to spend the $ to put her in a home. That is what she worked her whole life for, to be taken care of, not taken!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
You have become the 6th of grandma's children! and possibly the most responsible and dependable of the bunch. You are 27, have a nursing degree, and have lived at home (with grandma) most of your life!?! Yes, it's time to cultivate your independence. Old people often become more insecure & demanding as they lose their own independence. Don't let it become your tether.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Grandma has five children. Time for one (or a fewof them) to step up AND for you to be able to live your own life.

I'm glad things have worked out well until now - but Grandma is not your responsibility. Go out - live your life - spend time with you rboyfriend - garden in peace - get married if you feel like it . . . WE only get once chance at life ourselves. It may not be long before your immediate parents are also in need of some caregiving.

It's time for your to move on - with no guilt - and time for someone else to step up and assist Grandma.

Good Luck!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
honestly we have to take better care of ourselves, no one else cares to so we have to.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Debbie Cakes, my heart is with you. You are so very right, it is up to her children, not grandchildren, to decide what to do with mom. I have taken care of both parents until my mothers passing in June 2011. Now I have my 92 year old dad. Unlike what Dear Abby says, this is a full time job. Not one for the faint of heart. And certainly not one for the grandchildren. I have lost the past 10 years of my life and I know I will never get it back. I am old, wrinkled, gray, and the love of life in me was breathed into their bodies. Let the professionals do this. Your Aunts and Uncles are being unfair to you if they do not make it easy for you to leave and take the reigns themselves. I have a CNA coming in to help me 3 hours a day. My dad may live another 10 years. That will put me at 70. Here's a national statistic put out by Hospice: 60% of caregivers die before the person they are taking care of dies. Run....as fast as you can. Don't feel guilty...it's someone elses time.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Hey Thyme. I am in the exact same situation, only I am caring for my Grandfather as well. I am moving out. I'm 25. You see, you and I will be taking care of our parents some day. They all got to live their lives. We deserve ours too. You know what I started doing? I told my mom what she needed to do and that I was moving out. And guess what? She doesn't have a choice now, since I'll be gone sept 23rd. This is not our job. We are at that part of our lives where we need to be building our own life. It's not fair for our families to expect us to be the main caregivers. I tried, and I'm moving on. And it's okay for you to do this too. Don't let people guilt you into staying, that is manipulative and unfair. It's great that we tried to help our Grandparents, but we can't neglect ourselves. I am in the process of getting home health care in the home so that I can leave. My Grandparents are too mean and nasty for any family member to tolerate living here. If a nursing home is what they need...then that is where they will go. I am not a medical dr nor am I a psychotherapist. I am just a granddaughter who wanted to help, and they need much more than me. Hugs and good luck. Live your life. Let her children take over her care because one day you will be caring for your mother and you can't give your whole life over to caregiving.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
our MIL has last stage dementia, and lives w/us still. She cannot walk and doesn't know who we are now. We are keeping her home and doing the best we can. She barely eats now and has no congitive ability left. If she is still with us by the end of the year we have decided to put her in a home as we can no longer deal with the stress. We have 3 teenagers and it is starting to get rough. MIL keeps my family up all night sometimes and is never happy and you cannot make her happy. It is time for my family to be first. We have put her first for the last 3 years. It is really getting between us all. We are doing the best we can. Hang in there.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
I can relate. My mother is in asst. living. But I have no other family to help or support me. I have been dealing with her many health, financial, mental, and practical needs for about 5 years now, non stop. The SAD thing is there are 3 other siblings who dont even pick up the phone and call her. So, I feel like I have to meet all her needs with no support. I am thankful she
is in Asst. Living and am getting them to do alot of her follow up dr. appts. I am very concerned about what this is doing to my health. It is important for you to take care of yourself. Life is too short to feel it is always grueling. I struggle with this. So, I am taking practical steps to improve my life, while making sure my mother's needs are met. I have to! Perhaps you should sit down with your family (at least you have support) and work out a plan perhaps to get her more care so you can have a life. You at least, are young. I am 53, and want to live. My teeenage son has been neglected because of some intense seasons (hospital, rehab stays). And he has gotten into trouble. I have to make changes and you do too. We may always struggle with guilt, but if we know in our hearts we have done what we could, then at least we have that.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Thyme, part of me wonders if your grandma hadn't become difficult and cantankerous would you still want to move out? What if she had stayed the same, would that have made a difference or is it just time to move out? I think the answer to those questions might shed some light on what you will do. It was a wonderful thing to have a grandma so willing to have so many people come and go thru her house for as long as she did. Those are memories that you will never forget.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Oh my goodness I can totally relate to what you are saying, my sister and I lived with our grandmother for about 10 years, she just passed in February. You need to set some guidelines for yourself. My sister and I worked off each other the last 2 years when her health really started declining and yes she complained but as my sister put it well pick your battles with her. Sit down with her and make the grocery list include her it worked for us "Grandma what would you like from the grocery store" if it takes a couple of hours then it takes a couples of hours. She may feel her independence has been taken away. When you cook include her "Hey grandma, can you tell me how to make......" or if you have something that she can stir, mix, easy cutting bring the ingredents to her let her help prepare the meals. That is what we used to do with our gradmother. Maybe if she feels included in something she wont be so fussy or complaining when family members come over.

As far as guilt about moving on with your life, I thought that SO SO SO many times in the two years, for me the decision to move on with my life would result in her going into the nursing home and that was something I wasn't going to put her through, I gave up my life to make sure she stayed home till the end. Looking back I would NOT have traded it for anything in the world. If she were still alive I would still be doing it. That is something you must really sit back and think about. YOU AND ONLY YOU have to handle the outcome good or bad. If you choose to stay and continue to care for her will it be easy no you will feel stressed, tired, exhaused, overwhelemed, but you did it to the best of your ability. If you choose to move on that wont be easy either but you will be doing that to the best of your ability.

Now my sister worked a full time job in the day time so what we did that worked for us like I said we bounced off each other. I stayed home and took care of her from 730am-600pm then when my sister came home we had dinner touched basis on what went on through the day usally we on her way home from work, then I would go out and do my thing till 11 or 12 at night go to my aunts, church, walmart, something that got me a break but I could have my life as well.

I hope this helps you out.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

Recent Questions


Popular Questions


Related Questions

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter