My siblings and I are caregivers for parents. They live independently and we take them to dr. appts., grocery shopping, etc. Both parents showing signs of dementia, Poppy more than Mom. Mom is forgetful, but Poppy sometimes can't express himself coherently, and is better some days than others.
Poppy fell (again) the other day but this time, he couldn't get up. Went to ER and nothing broken. Sent home. He can't walk, so we got a hospital bed for him. He keeps wanting to get out of the bed and keeps falling because he has no strength. I don't think he will walk again after this, he is so weak. He is refusing any assistance, and won't go to his doctor for this fall.
I guess we are entering a new phase of caregiving. They won't be able to live independently anymore. Any guidance on whether Poppy should go to an assisted living facility, or else have someone come and live with them to care for him? Maybe what the pros and cons are, or how one makes the decision to do one or the other. Oh, and Mom is overwhelmed and stressed out and just wants him to go to a home.
This is where the medical and legal stuff converges, so any advice re: this aspect (medical and legal) would be welcome as well. We are trying to get POA signed, but no luck yet.
Thanks for any help you can give. Suddenly we have all these decisions to make and we don't know what to do.
Can you describe some of the decisions you are facing right now?
Your father really needs to see his doctor to get the ball rolling on this, so if he won't go, that's a problem. One of the best ways to make the transition to a care facility is from a hospitalization. If your doctor certifies that you need rehab, the hospital assists in finding a bed and Medicare generally pays for the first 20 days entirely.
I am not sure that Dad would be suitable for assisted living. If he can't walk, needs a hospital bed, often is not coherent, I wonder if he would be best served in a nursing home? Visit some of each and discuss his needs and their services with each. Since he cannot wander and assuming his behavior is not problematic, he probably will not need Memory Care.
Perhaps with Dad cared for elsewhere and Mom with mild dementia she might get by on her own with some in-home care for a while. Realize, though, that dementia gets worse, and that generally persons with dementia cannot live alone past the very early stage. If she is physically well she might qualify for assisted living at that point.
Having one parent in a care center -- let alone two in the future -- is going to be expensive. What is your parents' financial situation? How long would they be able to pay for this kind of care? Most people in this situation would eventually need to apply for Medicaid.
Getting each parent to name a POA for finances and for medical decisions will be a huge help along the way. It still does not give you the authority to place them in a care center against their will (for example) but it does facilitate acting on their behalf.
Consulting an attorney specializing in Elder Law would be very helpful at this point. This will help you avoid mistakes that would cause trouble with a Medicaid application and also expose you to options for handling their care.
Poppy is much better now that the stress and pain are wearing off. Biggest problem at the moment is toileting. He's too weak and frail to support his weight.. He can crawl. He keeps getting out of bed (mainly I think wanting to go pee) but falls and my brother is the only one with enough strength (and lives closest) to come over to get him back in bed. He has a diaper and a urinal but still keeps wanting to get out of bed.
jeanniegibbs, you brought up a point I hadn't considered, that if we had a signed POA, it wouldn't help because we still can't do anything against his will. We were thinking if we could just get that signed, that would open the door to get what he needs. Now I feel really powerless. He is proud and stubborn and refuses any aid. We were thinking of consulting either a geriatric care manager or elder law attorney to get a game plan on how to deal with a situation like this. Obviously this arrangement can't go on too much longer. Any suggestions for dealing with this? I feel like we are entering the First Circle of Hell and it's going to get worse before it gets better.
Something else you can do is contact your local state agency for elder affairs at the Dept of Human Services. Tell them the situation and ask if they can do a needs assessment. If you get a good social worker, he/she may be able to help a lot.
Good luck. Situations like this do work out, but we always hope it is in a good way.
How do you get them to sign the POA? I don't think he will sign it. Same re: evaluation by an MD. I am making an appt. with an elder law atty and his primary care physician, and none of us are entirely sure he will go to his dr., but we're going to try. How do they get diagnosis of mental status? If Poppy is told that's what the dr. is doing, I'm certain he'll just refuse to cooperate. And, no, we don't want the ED to cart him off to the first available bed. Wow. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and experience, all of you. I'm really glad I found this site.
Dementia patients lose their ability to make rational decisions, so no, he's not going to volunteer to go to the doctor even if he's in pain. He's not going to volunteer to move into a nursing home or dementia care residence. It doesn't matter what he wants. You have to do the responsible thing as his daughter and as a reasonable adult aware of the situation.
If you want to take your little kid to the doctor for shots, you don't just come out and tell them "Hey, get in the car now. We're going for shots! They're going to stick a needle in your little arm and it's probably going to hurt." Sometimes the less detail shared, the more cooperation you can get.
Dad HAS to be seen by a doctor, so you HAVE to do whatever it takes to get him there. You don't have to lie, but you also don't have to paint the whole vivid picture in 12 colors for him to reject and react to. You don't need his permission to do the right thing.
Ideally, you won't sit around waiting for another fall. YOU need to call a NEUROLOIST and make him an apointment. They need to look into why he is having such drastic weakness and can't walk or talk. These are red flags you need to attend to urgently. It could be neurological or something else. This is not optional or something you can put off to the future. DO IT NOW.
In the meantime, if he falls, or if he has an episode where he can't make sense, call 911, meet them at the hospital and request a cognitive eval by the ER team if they weren't already going to do one. I should hope that this would be procedure when they get an older person who has fallen. Tell them he has been confused to the point of not being able to speak, falls repeatedly, and you have safety concerns for him, since his only full time caregiver also has dementia and is not mentally or physically able to assume the role. Tell them he won't see his regular doctor over this and can't return home because it isn't safe, and he won't cooperate with bed rest. These are all words that will mean something in the ER and ought to trip some triggers. Do not sugar coat it. Do not whitewash it so it doesn't sound so bad. Tell them you are afraid for his safety at home. DO NOT volunteer yourself or other family to be caretakers. Make it 100% crystal clear he absolutely can in no way return home.
Just because nothing is broken does NOT mean he should go home. That's ridiculous and I would not accept that from any ER doctor. Care varies from place to place, but at any of our hospitals if they got a confused delusional old person in for falling, that patient would not be walking or wheeled out the doors to just go back home with zero follow up.
The ER should definitely perform some brain scans and have a neurology consult. There will be a crisis social worker at the ER you can talk to - request that they meet with you if they don't find you first. This person is a lynch-pin in getting going down the right direction.
The social worker and a hospital discharge planning team can help find a rehab location for your dad. This will buy you a couple weeks of time to make other permanent arrangements for him. Hopefully he can go to a facility that has rehab (also called Transitional Care Units) and can just reclassify him as a resident after rehab ends, instead of making him move to another facility for admission. He might have to move into a different room, probably semi-private. This is what happened with my mom.
That trip to the hospital can make a huge difference and open doors for you, but you have to know there are doors there in the first place!
I want to make sure you guys know that he really is pretty lucid MOST of the time afa knowing what's going on around him, but when it is about his autonomy or personal safety, he gets really resistant and that's when he starts not sounding rational.
So just checking to see if that makes a difference in your response, because I want to share this information with my siblings but I want to make sure we're on the same page.
My mother could fake it with anybody who didn't know how to ferret out cognitive decline. Answering your name and what year it is is NOT a cognitive evaluation. There are several out there - a mini mental or a SLUMP are two. You can NOT tapdance your way through these.
My mother is now in the severe stage of cognitive decline and can tell you her name, what grade my kids are in, and who is married to some of my husband's aunts. She still requires 24/7 supervision in a locked memory care unit.
You absolutely can NOT expect a dementia patient to be rational. The rational part of the brain is affected little by little until that capability is gone. Loss of reason looks like a person becoming grouchy, resistant, entrenched, and difficult. Loss of reason does not look like a catatonic drooling person in curled up in a chair, like TV would have us think.
If it were up to my mother, she insists she would be just fine thank you, alone in her house out in the country, eating spoiled food, taking prescriptions that expired 20 years ago, bathing in water that smells like rotten eggs.
You have to make sure the right doctors are looking at him. People educated in geriatric care and neurology of the elderly. Your run of the mill vanilla GP or family practice MD isn't going to ask the right questions or see past the surface (based on my experiences). My mother went for 15+ years with the wrong care because the stupid country GP she had didn't recognize her symptoms as dementia and gave her bad advice that probably has cost her years of good days.
Get him to a neurologist and start getting answers. This will disrupt the status quo, and everybody needs to be prepared.
When you get the right doctors involved, you & your siblings aren't making dad do anything. The doctors are. They do the tests that give the results and recommendations. It's not the family ganging up on him. Some folks take news better from an authority figure than from their grown kids. Even when the grown kids are 65+.
Moving my mom into a senior independent & assisted living apartment one year ago may have saved her life. She was actually much farther gone than any of us realized and should have been in the assisted living unit 10 years ago or more. She was only in the apartment for 6 months before more drastic changes happened that put her over in the nursing home unit of the same place. 4 months later and she had to go into the locked memory care unit. I am lucky to have a place where all of these care levels are under one roof. It's a big campus.
She and her sisters were not ready to accept reality, which prevented her from making life changes when they probably would have mattered. This has accellerated her decline, but I can't change the past. Mom & her sisters are exceptionally stubborn and one of their super powers is denial. Having this group stand around and pretend it's not happening did nothing to help mom out.
Being in the senior residence and nursing home unit probably saved mom's life. If she had been allowed to continue doing what she wanted, she would likely be dead right now from a fall, diabetic coma, malnutrition, overdosing, or another stroke. Pick one or pick three for a combo platter. She has had several very serious medical incidents this past year that would have had a very sad outcome had she not been in a place where there were competent medical professionals around her at all times.
That peace of mind is worth every penny it costs her to stay there. She is in an environment structured to meet her every need. There are no stairs, her food is prepared fresh at each meal and served to her. She is washed, her depends undergarments changed, and dressed every day by trained people. She is put into activities structured for people at her level.
I have been able to move out of caregiver, stop the obsessive worry, and go back into the role of daughter who visits. She resented me as caregiver. She fought getting care. Now, it's not me telling her to eat and it's not me making her take her meds. It's the people in charge. The doctor comes to them in the unit, so I don't have to take her out in the winter weather to appointments. If a med change is needed ASAP, the charge nurse just calls for the doctor to OK it and it's made up right there. They have a PT gym on site. There's a dentist on site. There's a barber & beauty shop on site. There's church on site. Activities, pet visits, musicians, you name it.
They do so much more than I could in my home or that mom could get in her home community.
Everybody wants to hang onto the "way it's always been" long beyond when it stopped being that way. Dad probably thinks he's independent in his own house when he really is not. If he can't walk, he's not independent. If he's having incontinence issues and requires assistance to change, he's not independent. If he needs his food prepped and brought to him, he's not independent. Independence is an illusion. If mom & dad don't know to call 911 when he falls, that is a sign there is a cognitive problem. When the frail fall, they can have damage that isn't visible on the outside. I would be worried sick about that. Falls can come from mini-strokes, dementia progression, and a host of other medical problems not obvious to the untrained.
No, a nursing home type facility is not where the able bodied & able minded want to live. Yes, we would be miserable there, but it isn't for us.
I realized that I can't quit my life to care for my mom, and I am also the last person on earth she wants to have caring for her, so the place I was able to get mom placed was a real God-send. She hates it because they make her get up, clean up, get dressed, and come out to eat in the common area. They put her at the table for activities and she hates it, but it's good for her. Sitting alone in the dark, sleeping all day, being up all night, and not getting her meds was not healthy. They don't let her be that way.
She's had the best medical care ever in her 77 years at this place, but won't ever appreciate it.
This kind of crisis is hard on everyone, so I'm sending you all the good vibes possible. Come back to ask any & every question. There are some amazing people on this board who helped me & I know they will help you too.
joannes, love your avatar...your pop is so cute. I am learning that communicating differently is key. I'm glad to know the "either this or that method" of letting them choose is effective. I'm going to remember that. I wish we could do the same thing you did with the attorney who drew up your trust. My parents' was done so long ago, I don't even think the attorney is still around but could try to find out.
Today I called an elder law atty who blew me off with some stupid response, so now will have to find another one. We have home aides coming out tomorrow for bath and hygiene stuff, and a geriatric case manager who is going to do an assesment and report. I hope she will be a good resource. I didn't have time to really shop around. You've gotta start somewhere, and whether it be right or wrong, just taking action makes me feel better.
It sounds like most people have generally had good experiences with assisted living/nursing home/whatever else. (I'm still learning the terminology and the difference between all these places!) That's really good to know. We'd like to keep mom and poppy at home if we could, but I guess there will come a time when it would probably make more sense to move them into a place.
Thank you thank you thank you all!
When looking for a placement for dad, you want to put him somewhere that can expand services as his need level increases. If he only needs X for skilled nursing today, and the place doesn't provide X + Y, that would be a strike against that spot in my book.
Not every area has continuum care facilities, but if you can find one, look into it seriously. Those facilities can handle many different levels of care. The one my mom is in goes from independent apartments all the way to hospice. I joke that you go in one end with your boxes and come out the other end in one. They have everything in between.
One question to ask is "what do you guys NOT provide?". or "when do you transition residents to the next level of care and is that care provided here?"
"What assistance do you provide in finding the next level of care when the need arises?" "What would I have to bring in an outside agency to take care of?"
Just an example of the care levels we use in my area -
Independent Living means the person may still drive their own car, but wants to live in a senior only environment. They may or may not require any help. These folks could come & go as they pleased, just like in a regular apartment complex, but they had the common dining room available for 20 meals a month, shuttle buses, activities & field trips you would not get at a normal apartment complex. They also had to call the "I'm OK" line by 10:00 every morning.
IL with services means the person has someone come setup their medication box for the week, or gets med reminders, and the like. Very lightweight care. Administration of meds is where it gets muddy between what a personal care aid can do vs. a skilled nurse. Aids can hand pills to the person and watch them take it but not do insulin injections for example. This definition is different in every state and even across facilities. You have to ask and never assume.
Assisted Living is where the person needs help transfering, dressing, bathing, other activities of daily living (ADLs). There's probably medication administration. But where mom is, the AL unit folks still came down to the same dining room as the IL group and joined those activities. There was another AL unit that had its own small dining room for the folks who were not able to get to the big dining room and who needed more help to start eating. These folks did not need 24/7 supervision and monitoring but did need help with bathing, dressing, transferring.
The Care Center is what they call the nursing home unit now. This is the unit for folks who need 24/7 monitoring, skilled nursing services and assistance with most ADLs. There is a higher nurse to patient ratio. There were people in this unit who were just really old, people with dementia, people with every kind of elderly affliction there is that requires skilled nursing services and 24/7 supervision. It's a lot more hospital-like than the AL unit.
The Memory Care Unit is locked and where the dementia patients with behavioral/psychiatric problems are. This unit holds the wanderers as well. This unit is pretty specialized to deal with people who have all kinds of behaviors that would keep them from being in another group setting and for the folks who need a lot of help with everything.
Hospice & Palliative Care unit is for people who may be transitioning to their final stage.
There's also a TCU/Rehab unit in the building for people who have had some kind of major surgery and need to recover for a long period and will then go back home. There's people of all ages in that unit.
Some areas have these levels across different facilities and when you need to change, you have to go find a spot in a new place and move there.
So can i ask everyone, what did you base your decision on to put your loved one in a facility? My sister wants to keep Poppy at home, if possible, and I did too at first, but now I'm starting to wonder, as I learn more about dementia.
He wanted to get out of bed this morning and Mom was trying to keep him in, and she said he "kind of" kicked her in the stomach! This is the first time I've heard of him getting physical over the past week. He's been very nasty verbally to her but she knows it's his dementia and says it doesn't hurt her feelings. She is living 24/7 with him and coping pretty well, but it's obviously harder on her than the rest of us who get to go back to our homes at the end of the day.
The GCM came out yesterday and will have her report by tomorrow. I wasn't there, but she told my sister Poppy's getting bedsores and needs to be turned every 2 hours, has a weird sore on his leg, among other things. Did a mini mental status exam on him. Recommended skilled nursing coming in to the home. I don't know what all else, but sis was pretty overwhelmed after hearing it all. We were thinking it would be better for everyone if he did go to some kind of facility. When my mom told me he kicked her yesterday, that was not a good thing. Plus he keeps trying to get out of bed, and if he needs round the clock care, we think it would be better to be in a facility.
So the plan is to make an appt. with his primary care for Friday. And then what? I remember now my sister said when he was taken to ER, they said if no POA, they can't keep him.
So we still don't have POA. We will have the GCM's report of his condition to take to the dr., but I don't know what it says yet. I am going to call GCM today and probably ask her the same things, but I've been learning so much from you all, I thought I would post this while I'm waiting for a decent time to call.
So if he needs nursing care and we have no POA, does that mean we can't take him anywhere because he will refuse?
What should we tell or ask the doctor that we want/need?
I'm too close to the situation right now to be concise and clear, and you know how doctors appts are always time sensitive. And since he didn't break anything, I don't know if his provider will provide any sort of care or anything, because now it is just old age stuff that is on us, right?
So I'm thinking of giving the report to the receptionist at check-in and telling her it's important that I speak to dr. before he sees my father, and then just telling him the key points because he'll already have the report. It's hard to distill everything into two or three clinical sentences when you're so emotionally involved and so much has happened in the last week and a half.
I think the GCM wants to delay a neuro consult until AFTER the POA is done. A POA would be invalid if the person is incompetent when they sign it. A neuro consult needs to happen, but things need to occur in the right order. OTHERWISE, there is a different process. You're not up a creek.
If a doctor declares him incompetent, then you go before a judge to recieve guardianship. It's a longer more complicated pathway, but it is possible.
TAKE WITH YOU TO THE GP: A list of symptoms you are worried about. If they don't hand you a form with a bunch of boxes to tick off for this, then you can bring it yourself.
E.g., Inability to comply with directions, anxiety, physical agitation, disrupted sleep, periodic inability to verbalize, incontinence started about X month of X year, confusion, paranoia, delusions, etc. Whatever it might be.
As far as home care, it's a fine idea when there's the possibility of recovery and return to normal. E.g. after a heart attack. With dementia, things can rapidly deteriorate literally over night into a situation a home is not equipped to handle.
It becomes extremely expensive to convert a home into a dementia-proof facility. And then you've lost your home. There isn't anywhere to go for your own rest & respite. If there's a dementia patient there, nobody will be getting anything remotely like rest. The entire household is affected and the patient becomes the center of the universe.
For me, I was not willing to do that to myself, my husband, or my kids. Our home is our sanctuary. If it were possible to do caregive without any kind of break from it, why do facilities run shifts? Even the professionals know to get away from it after a certain number of hours on duty. If it's in your home, there is no getting away, not even to pee.
My mother lived with us for a while, and it got to the point where she would go into hysterics if I were not in her line of sight. I literally could not go pee without her losing it. Even if I told her I went to pee, I'm still here, you're not alone. She would not let me or anyone else organize her meds. It was a destructive nightmare. My guest bedroom STILL has a weird smell in there we can't get rid of.
The choice comes down to the fact the person is going to live in a dementia care unit one way or another. Is that unit going to be in a place purpose built for it already or are you going to convert your home into a dementia care ward and expect everybody else to live that lifestyle?
The care needs starts out as a heavy burden and goes up, up , up. Many people come to this site in real crisis after deciding to take this on, and it turning into something they never expected in a million years. Go in with eyes open.
Make sure your sister knows that to care for dad at home will mean she has to effectively convert the house in many ways and be willing to live the dementia lifestyle 24/7/365 herself. Is she going to do that with mom too?
It is NO picnic. If a facility requires a cooking crew, a cleaning crew, a nursing staff, attendants, orderlies, activity director, care coordinators, and safety resources, why would someone think they can take all that on as one person?
The wear & tear on a home is enormous. Carpet cleaning & replacement, enormous laundry loads, etc.
Home care is an idea a lot of people are in love with because it sounds loving and caring, but the reality is more often something else completely.
We took him to his primary care dr. today. I had the report from the GCM and was sure when he saw everything wrong with Poppy, he would admit him. Well, in the waiting room before he saw the dr.,, he slipped down from his wheelchair and fell to the floor. It is protocol to call the paramedics, so they came over, and his BP was really low so they took him to ER. I thought, great, this is a blessing in disguise. Now they'll see all his problems and admit him.
Well, they did admit him for renal failure, of all things. He's barely eaten for the past two days. His BP is higher lying down than it is sitting up. No wonder he can't stand up and is dizzy all the time.
The admitting doctor starts tellling Poppy he is going to stay in the hospital and Pop's immediately trying to refuse and get out of it. Doctor tells him he has to stay and if he's stable he can be discharged tomorrow. I take doctor aside and tell him all that's going on at home and why Pop can't come home, with his dementia and falling all the time, etc. I say he can't come home, we are not equipped to take care of him. The doctor says they are not the police and if he wants to go, they have to let him go.
I spoke to case manager and told her the same thing, and she said he could be transferred to a nursing home, but if he is getting out of bed all the time, they will put him in a locked ward. They could transfer him to a rehab for the short term, but the social worker will be there tomorrow and they can tell me more about it.
I talked to our geriatric case manager, and she said if they want to discharge him, make them show you documentation re: why his BP is so low, and why he can't stand up without falling down. So I guess kind of as a stall tactic, more than anything else.
I asked her about the results of the mini mental status exam she performed on him, and it was actually pretty good, like no real dementia going on, and because he has a possible UTI, that could be the cause for some recent agitation and confusion and some things he missed on the mini. Then she kind of ran out of ideas and suggested trying to talk him into assisted living or something. Yeah, right. That is not going to happen.
So it still seems like it comes down to, if he doesn't want to go anywhere for treatment, there's nothing we can do about it. I didn't have the heart to tell my mother that tonite. They have the money to pay for round-the-clock care, so I guess that's what they'll have to do. I know he has dementia but I apparently it isn't that bad. It's just that he will not help himself by always trying to walk when he can't, and making things worse.
And I don't even have it as bad as what some of you are going through. Really, I don't know how you do it.
Ask discharge planning if they are certifying him as safe to be discharged to go home alone, because your mom has dementia and can no longer care for him.what do THEY suggest as the level of care he needs to be safe? Have the doctor write an order for home care, visiting nurse, bath aide, in home pt. When dad complains about it, say, "the doctor's say you have to have this or you have to go to assisted living"
Take your parents on some AL tours in the coming weeks. Have them think about the coming winter months if you live someplace with bad weather. Sometimes you can convince them to go for a month's trial, and they like it!
Babalou, things have been changing so quickly. Dr. called yesterday. Poppy has pneumonia and a mass on lung which is probably cancer, but discouraged biopsy on such an old person because of its own complications, and he's not a candidate for surgery with all of his other health problems. So he was saying treating the cancer with chemo is an option, I guess. He said he has months to live.
Next option is nursing home for a limited time, which I means Medicare or insurance pays for and then you must pay after that period is over. Am I understanding that right?
The last option is hospice which Medicare pays for. But my boyfriend said he probably wouldn't qualify for Medicare because he has too much money. So do we need to start looking for a hospice care service? I think they will keep him in hospital for one more day while we decide. If/when we bring him home, I think he will have to have 24/7 care for his bedsores because he has to be turned every 2 hours. I am sure he would want to be home instead of in a hospice facility.
Any advice about this new development?