Follow
Share

The Care Center my dad lives in recently opened for visitors on March 24th.
My dad did not have visitors for over a year as they closed the doors March 12th in Montana. My dad is confused and I don't know how he survived for over a year without family! I Skype with him a few times. He lost weight and his quality of life is nonexistent.
My brother has said 3 times(!) He would show up for a visit and never does! My dad is a widow and I am his only visitor at this point. My husband visits a little also.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
My brother lived first a mile from my mom's nursing home, then lived IN HER HOUSE (also a mile away), and still never went to see her unless I was there, too.

I can't explain why he acts like that because he does care about her, but he doesn't handle old people and their infirmities well, I guess. I don't worry about it anymore. I moved Mom closer to me (I live an hour from her last place), and he's been to see her a total of four times in two years.

I can't control his behavior, and I'm not going to stress myself out over it. As with many things I can't control, I just say "it is what it is" and move on.

Don't tell your dad your brother is coming to visit, so he won't be disappointed. If Bro shows up, it'll be a nice surprise.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

It’s hard. I have a daughter who seems to be still angry about my breakup with her father in her younger days, and by regrets that my DH2 doesn’t live up to the standards she thought I should achieve, status-wise. She is very very image conscious, in the medical profession which is riddled with snobbery. I haven’t seen her for 3 years. I can’t understand it, DH2 is a qualified experienced engineer, far better qualified than she is (as am I), far better off (as am I), also both than her father DH1. Her father had the most beautiful BBC accent, but fewer brains or achievements. For whatever reason, she just doesn’t want to know about me and DH2. My other daughter says that she loves me, but she certainly doesn't show it. It breaks my heart. I can’t fix it, just cope with it. You may need to do the same thing. Commiserations!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
JoAnn29 Apr 2021
So sorry Margaret.
(3)
Report
Well, we can all try to guess why your brother doesn't show up, or you could just ask him.

Three dates he's let go by in less than two weeks. Depending on how firm the arrangement was, how far he has to come and what else he has to organise, that doesn't sound like he's determined never to let your father see him again.

Pick up the phone and call him. There's probably a good reason, and you can encourage him in a positive, cheerful way to drop in as soon as he can.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

My uncle was in a nursing home for two years and one of my cousins never went to see him.

No one knows why my cousin didn’t go visit him.

I truly feel that some people can’t handle it emotionally. They want to remember them as they were when they were well.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Daughterof1930 Apr 2021
My brother used to say that bringing his children to the nursing home to see my mom was too hard on them and he wouldn’t do it. Truth was he couldn’t handle it. Nobody bought his excuses, but we accepted that we couldn’t control his decisions. My now adult children are quick to say they learned tremendously from those visits, it grew their character and helped them learn to think of others
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
This is what some people do. You cannot change your brother’s actions by being upset about them yourself.

“Promises made” become either “promises kept” or “promises broken”. It took me over a year, and several sessions with a good counselor, to understand that one of two POAs selected with trust and confidence by my LO would be 1,000 miles away for the hard stuff and the long haul.

I’m not sure it’s actually possible for any of us who have been locked away from LOs in residential care to assess how well or how poorly the folks in this situation fared, but whatever their situations were, we who love them MUST pick up the pieces wherever they’ve fallen, AND MOVE ON.

Don’t overestimate how much your father’s welfare depends on your absent brother, and for sure, don’t UNDERESTIMATE how much your contacts mean to him!

Your energy and love and strength are what your dad needs, whenever you can get to him. Don’t waste them on your brother’s conduct. This is what it is.

For your welfare AND YOUR DAD’S, LET IT GO.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Actually this is a question for your brother. My one brother told my DH he just couldn't see Mom that way. My other brother, I tthink may have felt the same way. But then neither went out of their way before her Dementia, so really not surprised. And she was a good Mom. We had the house all our friends gathered at.

Its hard to watch a parent decline. I watched it every day.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

in a family every sibling has their own private relationship with a parent that each of the other household members are not privy too. You may feel good about your relationship with your father, maybe your brother does not.
Me: even though I am caring for my parents, don't feel close to my parents, my history with them is mine and for me I did not and do not find it one that has proven to be a warm, fuzzy relationship. On the other hand my siblings might feel differently, towards them, I don't know. There are many private moments we experience with our parents that form our history with them. Personally mine was not one I cherish :) I still love them, but, I think that if they were elsewhere, I would avoid seeing them also.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My sister swans around visiting friends/vacationing. She has visited our mother 2 times in 5 years. Mom is hurt and angry about it. My sister says she dislikes our mom and did her share for her already. I think she will regret her attitude when mom is gone, but that’s her problem. You can’t make someone be the person you want. Do your thing; you only have your own conscience to control.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
help2day Apr 2021
I wouldn't count on your sister "regretting" she didn't visit your Mom. My sister lived ONE mile from our Mom and would MAYBE visit on Mother's Day or her birthday (which was 2 weeks apart) so the two visits in May were it for the year. Our Mom was very lucid and knew her only other daughter didn't visit and I know it hurt her feelings. I was angry but thought after she died, my sister would have regrets. Nope. I just don't understand. I was our Mom's caregiver and I know I don't have any regrets. Make peace with it. She won't change and it will only naw at you and make you miserable. At this point, I rarely see my sister and it no longer bothers me. Her loss.
(4)
Report
You need to let this go. My brother has not visited my dad for a couple years. He calls him a few times a year but my dad doesn't know who he is anymore. We talked about this recently. He is grieving his loss of the dad he used to know and this is how he chooses to deal with it. I respect his decision. He prefers to remember him as he used to be.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

This could be a form of grieving for your brother. He may not be able to emotionally handle seeing his Dad this way. When i was young, I couldn't handle seeing my Granddad that way. I would feel like crying and get very upset and depressed after each visit. I didn't want to spend the visit crying in front of my Granddad and others. I don't think I had the maturity or emotional fortitude to handle it back then.

You don't mention if your brother is local or if even is interested in updates about your Dad. If he is local, you could offer to go see Dad together for a brief visit and then you two could do something fun afterward (or before and after). If that goes well, you could make it a joint visit from time to time coupled with some fun together to make it more tolerable to him and help him get more acclimated.

If he is not local, you could ask him to come and visit you for a week or a few days. Once there, you could suggest one or two brief visits to Dad in between all of your fun together. He may agree with your belief in his ability to handle the visit, and the promise to keep the visit very short (like 30 minutes). Best wishes.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I am the only person in the past two years who has been inside the ALF where my parents live. I am the only one who has stood in the parking lot talking to them on the phone while they stood on their balcony or at their window in cold weather so I could physically see them during lockdown. My out of state sibling has FaceTimed them many times which has helped keep their spirits high. However local family members drive past all the time. It is very disappointing. It can be overwhelming when you are someone's only social contact with the outside world. Lower your expectations. Don't tell your brother when you visit. He can arrange his own visits. You haven't said what your relationship with your dad is so I would say visit your dad and keep it light and pleasant. Leave if it gets unpleasant. If dad asks about your brother just say you don't know and change the subject. Live your life.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My sister and I live in the same neighborhood as my parents and she hasn't been there since Christmas despite my dad needing constant care. I finally had to accept that she isn't coming, she's not going to help, and Im on my own. It helped me a lot to just accept it. It hurts knowing that a sibling could leave a parent to die alone. At least he has you. Be thankful that you can still have some experiences with your father and that he isn't completely alone.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

My husband rarely calls his mother - who has dementia - in Hawaii. She has a full time caregiver and rarely gets out of her little, efficiency condo. She doesn't really remember her oldest son, and last phone call she cried saying he was dead (her husband is dead and she miscarried her first male child). The phone conversations are always short and always the same. He feels frustrated with trying to communicate.

If your dad doesn't remember like my MIL doesn't, they guys may feel it is not worth the effort. They may also feel helpless to change his situation. Seeing dad this way may also remind them that this may be their future. Of course, the only way you'll know is to ask the guys and hope they will give you an honest answer.

If visits are tough for them, encourage them to reach out in other ways. My MIL appreciates that we send her fruit arrangements for the holidays that she and her caregiver can enjoy together. I send her long, chatty letters with pictures of ourselves, our children, and outings. I am fairly sure your men might be up for these kinds of activities. May one can trim his hair every couple of weeks and give a barbershop quality shave with hot towel treatment and neck rub. Maybe, they would be up for bringing dad a treat to enjoy with coffee and read the news to him.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Try not to stress about it. We all deal differently and it sounds like your brother can't face the reality of it. Lots of people are like this but you can't change it. All you can do is be there for your dad and control your own feelings about your brother.
Do you update him? If so, consider stopping temporarily and see if that prompts him to act to find out on his own. Sometimes we provide people with enough information for them to feel involved, so that even though they don't participate much, they feel like they are do.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I have a suggestion for relations who find it difficult to visit aging relative, send a greeting card or letter. Keep it generic but caring. Elderly can reread the message every day and it warms their loved one’s heart
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

It probably makes your brother too sad to see his father decline. Hopefully, your father is just dealing with whatever is happening in the moment and is not particularly distressed by what or who is not there.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

The only reason your brother does not visit is because he cannot "deal with it" - it being the decline in your father's health and a reminder of his own mortality.

I experienced a similar thing with my own brother and my widowed father, so you are not alone.

If your father is still cognizant and asks why your brother does not visit - be honest. Tell him that it is "too painful" for your brother to see him in his current state of health - so he avoids coming.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Invisible Apr 2021
That's kind of blaming the victim.
(0)
Report
Only you brother can answer that.

Sone people just don't like being in places like old folks homes and Hospitals as it makes them feel uncomfortable.

Maybe he just doesn't like seeing Dad like this.

Maybe he doesn't know what to talk about.

You should tell him that it hurts yours and Dad's feelings that he doesn't go and to please visit Dad once a week as he doesn't have anything else to look forward too.

Ask your brother if he would like to visit while you're there too.

Can you pick Dad up from the place or wheelchair him outside for a picnic?

Prayers
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

If your brother is uncomfortable seeing your dad in that setting, perhaps you can arrange a video chat with him and dad while you are visiting. It doesn’t have to be a long one and it will give your brother a chance to focus only on seeing dad and not his surroundings. Also, perhaps it will bring joy for your dad to see his son on camera. Some family members cannot accept their love one’s decline. Video allows them just a small glimpse to visit with them.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You can't change others. You can't force others to act as you want them to. Continue to visit with your Dad. Your brother's choices and reasoning isn't known to any of us. It will be for him to deal with when your Dad is gone. Just continue to do the best you can for your father. I wish you the best.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

It is bewildering why some do or not do things as we think they should. That is the answer, your brother and you are different people. My advice is stop wondering and worrying about others actions. We can only control our choices. Yes, everyone deals with life experiences differently. Some really cannot deal with parents aging. Maybe it is too difficult for your brother. No, to you it makes no sense. I completely emphasize because I am experiencing same situation. I have accepted it, no, I do not understand it, but acceptance will give you peace. What I do, is keep my sister updated on our mom’s health and put the matter in her hands. If she takes action or not, it is her choice. Now I know it is difficult and frustrating but you deserve peace with this.
I also highly recommend giving it to God. Allow Him to carry your burden. He loves you, your brother and your dad. He knows the entire situation and trusting and relying on God, will give you His peace.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I just went through that. He probably doesn't come because her cannot handle seeing his father like that.
I had such a hard time wondering about that as my brother was going to give me respite but only did once.
Now that my father has passed away, and he did help towards the end, we are closer than ever.
So there is hope but just do what we do for our parents in need and things will work out. Do not worry about this as caregivers we have too much to worry about and you probably can't fix this now. Just focus and take a breath, got you and Dad.
"And we breathe"
Trust in God.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

My youngest sister is the same way with regard to visiting mom, in memory care. She lives and works about 5 minutes away, the closest of any family, but she rarely visits. She was going to join me on the first day that memory care reopened to visitors, but cancelled at the last minute. Since then, I've visited multiple times a week, and my other brothers/sister have visited, my daughter has visited twice. But the youngest daughter? No chance. And she and brother will inherit everything mom owns when she passes, which is worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. The rest of the family will get nothing. I don't understand her lack of caring and generosity towards her mother.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My sister and her husband lived 1.5 mi. from my Mom and they would not go to see her. My sister would show up every few months. Her children, my nephews, would go by there and "borrow thousands of dollars" from my parents. They would also steal my dad's morphine when he was alive as well as pilfer from my Mom's wallet. My sister and her husband showed up at the hospital when I thought Mom was dying in Nov. and that was the first time I had seen my brother in law in 6 years. Then he had the audacity to criticize his 97 year old mother in law of "not being nice to them". I was there myself a lot of the time and she was very depressed and anxious. Then after I transferred Mom out to SNF they wanted me to post kudos that they visited while she was hospitalized. I blew up. I asked them where they had been last 10 years while I was trying to help our parents (and I live an hour away). Meanwhile their little spawns are now running drug rehab houses in a small town (go figure one is a felon from drug arrests and embezzling). One is "Christian" but never shows up to help Mom unless he needs money (borrowing while he was driving a mercedes and lexus and bought a new house). This is my only family. I have to let it go as the anger can be consuming. I have sent nice letters begging any of them to visit Mom in AL where she is having trouble adjusting. Mom finally did get one email from my sister but the rest of the crew will not come around unless they need money. I am Christian, and one nephew is Christian. His behavior towards his grandmother is astoundingly bad. I have to let it go. My Mom has said just to ignore them. She is very hurt. I am hurt but as one friend said to me, what do you expect from them. That is pretty typical behavior for years. Somehow I just thought they would support Mom emotionally after Dad died. I was wrong.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I agree with TheBuringBush. Just call your brother and ask him why he says he’ll visit and then doesn’t show up. You have the right to ask him.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Not an excuse but maybe an explanation
It is very hard for all of us to see any loved one decline.
And the thought of visiting..
What do I say
What do we talk about
How am I going to sit and do noting for an hour or more
It is a Saturday, I have worked all week and I have stuff that needs to get done around the house
It is Saturday and I have worked all week and I want some time for myself to unwind
I hate the smell of that place, it smells like, urine, poop, old people....
That is not the way I want to remember dad
He will not know if I visited, and/or he won't remember I was there

Don't concern yourself with your brother not visiting,. That choice is on him not you.
If dad asks say.."I don't know when he is going to visit."
When dad dies your brother will miss him as much as you do, he will feel sad like you will. Will he be sorry that he did not visit more, possibly. But it is not your responsibility to make sure he visits. your brother is an adult his actions and the consequences are his.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
gdaughter Apr 2021
Nailed it again Gram. How can one person (like you) be so darn smart? And this explanation falls no doubt on the siblings that have moved away except they have the convenient excuse of distance, and cost/now covid risks of traveling. My sibling took off ahead of the aging crisis mode to avoid it all and leave it in my lap with a comment about how I was entitled to my life as well (obviously her own selfish perspective and not caring to do a thing for her parents) and if mom and dad couldn't manage put them in a home or someplace. In fact you may have read prior here in my comments that this same sibling (my only) claimed I brought my own serious illness (aortic dissection from which most die) on myself and made my own decisions in re to my life (continuing to live with our parents while I work part time as a social worker no less). Yes I skipped marrying a loser and watching my savings blow away through a messy divorce as she did. Yes I do feel an obligation toward these demanding and exhausting people that trigger the high blood pressure I didn't know I had which contributed to my illness no doubt. She feels zero responsibility for anyone. Was out of work and could have been here, but I understood her need to be home to tend to two elder kitties whom she had no one to trust to look after them. Rarely responds to my emails which at times I let her know exactly what is going on here. I suspect an email from me is automatically deleted. It all makes me so sad because while my 98 year old mother is the one diagnosed with dementia, my father who will be 104 in less than a month is becoming perhaps because of my own recuperation, seemingly more stupid and demanding. I am haunted by a comment the neurologist made when assessing mom...that sometimes older people are sharp...as a tack:-) I am nearing retirement but currently working remotely which is both a blessing and a curse. Yesterday was an absolute nightmare and I am still exhausted from the episode which started with my going downstairs for something to eat and witnessing a trail of poop smears from the door of our kitchen to the opposite side (about 15-20 feet--it's oblong). And when I walked in there was literally a pile of soft poop on a rug by the kitchen sink. She had walked in it and then went on a tour of the family room leaving a trail. My father had obviously seen it and in his inept cleaning style had made a huge spot on the small powder room (flat) carpet. And he had left. He can't comprehend that she cannot be left alone. I took my pup out and while my mother is prone to constantly UNlocking the damn door, while we were outside she LOCKED us out. She was standing within feet of the door when I noticed and pounded and screamed and cursed to open the door/let us in, and proceeded to walk away. The saving grace was that my ignorant father left the gate unpadlocked and I had my set of housekeys with me as now I take no chances and lock our bedroom door when we leave...so we walked around to the front and got back in. I spent hours using disinfecting wipes cleaning the kitchen floor (might get to steam mop it later). She managed to lock me out AGAIN when I was outside scrubbing the ruined rug. And although he claimed to have tried to find what leaked in the cupboard, it was me at 12:30 AM who was looking for the source which was oddly a marinara sauce jar with a hole in the side. On the top shelf. And then he wants to know this AM how " I feel". Oh, and when he'd left the house, he'd gone to buy more rug cleaner, which is also ineffective. I sprayed with a particular pet product good for all the nasties, but never got back to it at the appointed time. The suggestion of nursing home etc will only generate more stress and result in my parents doing worse...running out of space to explain...but it's not an answer on many levels including financial and will only result in MORE stress for me. Per MD best way to help me is keep BP low. LOL.
(1)
Report
How far away is he? What kind of a schedule must he adhere to? What was the prior relationship? Is he terribly upset by seeing the illness? Does he just simply not care? These are some possible reasons. It is sad but face it, you can't force this on him if he just does not do it. Just try to be kind and loving even if your brother is not. I know personally, I freak out when I have to enter a nursing home - my heart goes out to those poor people but afterwards I have nightmares and have a terrible time emotionally dealing with what I have seen.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Invisible Apr 2021
The more time I have spent with my father in the care facility, the less I am bothered by it. Instead, I tried to get to know the staff, other residents and their families to encourage them to interact with my father so he wouldn't feel like a prisoner.
(1)
Report
My brother would visit my dad and most of the time it would end with my brother screaming at our dad. Dad was heartbroken after his visits. I wished he would have stayed away.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Same here. It’s been 10 yrs & he’s visited maybe once each year. He used his career as an excuse but when he retired he moved as far away as could to the coast. Now he says his next move is to the other coast. He doesn’t even ask about her anymore. He rationalizes how good it is for me to be her sole caregiver. But I lost my own career, my marriage, all my work friends & sacrificed my life. The only good thing I have in my isolation is that I live on a farm & I have a lot of hobbies & things that need to be done while she naps. People that tell you not to be concerned that you’re doing everything & your sibling has gone awol haven’t been there. I only have 1 sibling & he over rationalizes things he makes up in his head to prevent guilt & a feeling of any responsibility. I think he’s lacking integrity & is completely selfish without empathy. We don’t need the likes of him which is a good thing since he’s not there for us anyway.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I had a good friend who suffered from brain cancer. I visited him weekly the last year of his life while other close friends avoided him. They would tell me what a great friend I was and how they "couldn’t face seeing him like that." Yes, it was difficult seeing his decline but I kept reminding myself of the Golden Rule my mother taught us - "do unto others how you would have them do unto you."

That being said during the last few years of my parents lives one brother, the golden favored child, rarely visited. I and my other brother visited regularly, helped with chores, dr visits, etc. The first thing they would ask was "have you heard from X?" At first I would offer excuses for him but after a while I would just say "don’t know, why don’t you call him and ask him why he doesn’t visit?"

In truth, I was not my brother's keeper. My only consolation was that his actions would come back to haunt him when he was an old man and this is the example he was showing his children and grandchildren. Sadly he died at age 62, but his daughter, who lived 2 miles from Mom's AL, never visited her grandmother.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter